4 ms·
The own their wealth jointly. There is no 20x different in net worth. In a community property state, any wealth made during their marriage is shared. For exampl
by eesmith 7y ago
The own their wealth jointly. There is no 20x different in net worth. In a community property state, any wealth made during their marriage is shared. For example, in divorce it could be split equally between the two.
Again, DHH is not 20x richer than his wife. They are equally rich under the law. (Excepting any money that DHH made before the marriage, which, given that it was a long time ago, is likely a small part of that wealth.)
This all came up recently during the divorce between Jeff and MacKenzie Bezos. Amazon started after their marriage, and since Washington is a community property state she was entitled to 1/2 of their shares in the divorce. It wasn't that Jeff was 10,000x richer than MacKenzie was.
Please note the subtle distinction between what you wrote: "They claim they don’t know the person’s gender." and the additional qualifier GS used "during the Apple Card application process".
They very likely know that she is a woman, and married. Their statement is that those aren't considered during the application process.
Thus, it's possible that I am not wrong, and that they are not lying.
They don't need to know one's gender or marital status to violate anti-discrimination laws, so I don't see the point of discussing that detail further.
- zepto 7y agoAll this talk about community property is well known but not relevant. It is during the application process that the credit amount is decided on and offered, and that is what the complaint about. So how is it relevant to this discussion if they find out later?
- eesmith 7y agoIf you believe that it's relevant to claim 'It seems entirely possible that DHH has 20x her net worth' then it's relevant to point out that they have equal net worth, making your claim likely incorrect.
- zepto 7y agoIt’s not at all likely that their net worth is equal unless you assume they both had equal net worth before they were married, which itself is highly unlikely. More importantly, the net worth you are referring to is only the value that would be established in the event of a divorce, and indeed could only be established with the knowledge that they were married. Since GS doesn’t know about the marriage when they make the credit offer, we know the figure you are using has no relevance whatsoever to the calculation they do use. Do you actually now acknowledge that they don’t know the marital status or gender of applicants when they offer the credit, or are you still denying that? If you do, why do you keep bringing this up?
- eesmith 7y agoI have already addressed all of these points earlier. Eg, you write "which itself is highly unlikely" while I wrote "Excepting any money that DHH made before the marriage, which, given that it was a long time ago, is likely a small part of that wealth." You are of course free to have different opinions than I do, but I find it tedious as it appears you are not reading what I have written. I keep bringing this up because you are making what appear to be very weak statements, then using those to suggest a stronger conclusion than it warranted. Consider your earlier phrase "It seems entirely possible that DHH has 20x her net worth." This has a double layer of uncertainty - 'it seems' means it's your opinion and 'entirely possible' means that you are accepting anything except which is clearly impossible. These are weak statements. In this case, what does "net worth" mean, how does GS determine their individual net worths, and how does it affect the credit process? As DHH wrote, "We have no separate bank or credit card accounts or any separate assets". Can you tell why you believe DHH might have 20x her net worth? Other than as hypothetical constructed to defend the actions of a multinational company?
- zepto 7y agoDHH might have 20x her net worth because athough it was a long time ago, he had already been an owner at 37 signals for a few years before he got married. Appreciation of assets owned before a marriage does not automatically contribute community property - only income and newly acquired assets do. DHH’s answer may further give insight into why she was offered a low amount. If he is named as the primary account holder then it may not show up on her credit reports even if it’s a joint account. But so what? These facts aren’t relevant. Even if I’m wrong about them it doesn’t matter. I agree they are weak and that this is why you are bringing them up. You are bringing these weak statements up to avoid responding to the real problem with your position: They don’t know her gender or that she’s married to him when they make the assessment. Do you still claim that they do?