3 ms·
Technically, a human can't draw a human. A human can only draw something that looks like a human to another human. The human viewer is doing most of the work by
by wpietri 7y ago
Technically, a human can't draw a human. A human can only draw something that looks like a human to another human. The human viewer is doing most of the work by imagining that the drawn human is real (or by recalling the real human suggested by the drawing).
As an example, consider all of these ASCII stick figures:
http://www.ascii-art.de/ascii/s/stickman.txt http://www.ascii-art.de/ascii/s/stickman.txt
Clearly, it isn't necessary to deeply comprehend the essential nature of humanity in order to draw one.
Knowing how a mind works well enough to build one is an immense task. A better analogy would be building a human body from scratch, which is also something humans can't do.
- solipsism 7y agoThe philosophical musings about what it means to "draw a human" are pedantic and really not relevant. My point is that "dog cannot do dog-related task" does not imply or even suggest that "human cannot do human-related task". It's pseudo-logic of the sort that is unfortunately often very convincing to people.
- wpietri 7y agoThey are relevant because you used "draw a human" to prove something wrong. If mine was irrelevant, so was yours. The reason "dog brain can't design an artificial dog brain" is a useful contribution is that it gives people an intuitive understanding of a complex truth: things can't fully model themselves. Dogs can't fully understand dogs. People can't fully understand people. It's plausible to me that humans can evolve something akin to AGI. It's also plausible to me that a vast number of humans working together will manage to stumble into creating AGI. But I see no reason to think that humans have the intellectual capacity to understand a human-level mind well enough to build one intentionally.