3 ms·
I'm always confused with these types of articles. "Will AI cause job loss" or "Will AI create jobs" aren't really the important questions. Because those questio
by godelski 7y ago
I'm always confused with these types of articles. "Will AI cause job loss" or "Will AI create jobs" aren't really the important questions. Because those questions are about net gain and loss, because yes it will cause job losses and yes it will create jobs. But that's not what's important to the average person.
If your job is automated away, what are you going to do? Hypothetically let's say that AI can accomplish everything that an X-ray tech can (or that with the help of automation a single tech can do what 10 techs do today). What happens to those people? They spent a lot of time and money getting that training. Retraining programs suck and are shown to be really ineffective. So do these people just go underemployed the rest of their lives? What about people who are 10-15 years from retirement? Even if retrained you go from peak earnings to starting wages. That's a huge disrupt in life.
Job loss is extremely important to consider (assuming you care about people), even if the total number of jobs are increased. We've seen this in the past and we're seeing it today. Lots of automation came into farming and many of those jobs disappeared. Family legacies were lost. But at the same time it is inhumane to not allow the progression of technology (like we could even stop it...).
My concern is that people aren't discussing the transitions of economies. We all want to live in a post scarcity world like Star Trek. Where food, housing, and basic essentials are effectively trivially obtained (for the most part in the show). But transitioning to that kind of society is extremely disruptive and has a lot of pitfalls on the way. It isn't unimaginable to ask "What if 10% of your population is unemployable?" (several scenarios: jobs just automated away; only existing jobs require high skill and training; transition period where those people are trained for jobs that recently got automated away; etc) What do we do? How do we handle that? We're a society where people still believe your worth correlates with your wealth (diction intended). I see very few people talking about this, and these kinds of scenarios are plausible within the next 50-100 years.
Net gains or losses of jobs is a distracting question and the wrong one to ask.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI basically went through this by getting divorced after two decades as a homemaker. I spent several years homeless. I previously had a class in Homelessness and Public Policy while studying to become an urban planner. Some things that would help a whole lot: 1. We need to address our housing issues. This isn't necessarily disastrous if you can move to some little hole in the wall in a walkable area with good transit so you can still have a life while living on meager earnings and retraining. The problem is that we've torn down about a million SROs in the US and the average size of new housing has more than doubled since the 1950s, so there just aren't enough places like that. 2. We need to resolve our healthcare issues in the US. Healthcare costs something like 20% of GDP and disproportionately negatively impacts poor people, unemployed people and people with chronic health issues (who are often pushed into poverty by that fact). If you can go to a doctor no matter how poor you are, these problems are vastly less likely to snowball out of control. 3. We need to embrace gig work and figure out how to make it a positive instead of decrying it and vilifying it. When I was deathly ill and homeless, gig work was a godsend. My earning capacity gradually went up and I eventually got back into housing. I still struggle, but it's better than it used to be. Gig work allowed me to develop an earned income and marketable skills at a time and under circumstances where no regular job would have worked, yet all I seem to ever hear is how evil it is. It's not inherently evil, though certainly some gig work is handled in a problematic fashion that keeps workers trapped in a dead end.
- iudqnolq 7y agoJust want to say I frequently see your comments not get many replies, and at least in my case it's because you're so comprehensive and right I don't have anything to say.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway35784 7y agoThe cost of a house has gone from $30k in 1940 to $220k today, inflation adjusted. I totally feel you on that and I'm dedicated to changing that. I'm designing my own house now with the idea to simplify and automate as much as possible. Minimum viable house. I blame the banks to a large degree. 30% of income for 30 years is obscene cost for a house. I am committed to mortgage free living. I'm sorry to hear about your struggles and very glad you are doing better.
- triceratops 7y agoWorkers that are automated away should be offered buyouts. If that's not cost-effective, then maybe the automation isn't such a great idea.
- godelski 7y agoI'm not sure that is cost effective. It can be long term cost effective, but companies generally don't operate with that much flexibility in their yearly budgets (i.e. if you have excess money to spend, spend it to improve your product).