3 ms·
> Answerers who downvote are people who genuinely want to help - they are spending their free time answering questions on the internet for no gain other than ex
by BeetleB 7y ago
> Answerers who downvote are people who genuinely want to help - they are spending their free time answering questions on the internet for no gain other than extremely localized imaginary internet points.
I think it's more accurate to say that answerers who downvote want to give answers (vs genuinely want to help). Because explaining to someone why their question is problematic is part of helping.
- KKPMW 7y agoThis is more nuanced. And StackOverflow as a website themselves are part to blame. They cannot seem to make up their mind if they are there to help the people who ask questions, or if their task is to construct a database of problem-answer pairs for future reference, like a type of programming encyclopedia. For the longest time everyone on the site believed it to be the "database" model. And helping individual users with their questions is not part of it. Under this framework answerers who downvote are simply doing what they are expected to do - weeding out poor entries from the encyclopedia. And the person who asks a question has no right to expect an answer, as stated in their 2011 blog entry: > We believe asking questions on our site is a privilege, not a right. [1] However recently they seem to be moving away from that model and only time will tell what it morphs in to. [1] https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-not-sand/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-...
- jrumbut 7y agoI think they've made a lot of progress with the "be nice" thing. A lot of the complaints in this thread I would have heartily agreed with 4-5 years ago, but they seem dated to me now. Maybe it's my perspective that's changed, that's always a possibility. The database model has never seemed right to me, but I do think SO is making progress moving away from it. Ironically, I believe they will be better able to achieve the database goal once they let it be an emergent property of Q&A rather than grudgingly allowing Q&A to get the database.