3 ms·
No, by "if you're serious" I mean about having an answer. Sometimes people ask questions on a whim and, after an hour or two, don't really care. But sometimes
by ColinWright 7y ago
No, by "if you're serious" I mean about having an answer. Sometimes people ask questions on a whim and, after an hour or two, don't really care. But sometimes people really want an answer, so they are serious about finding out.
Equally: "... would a collision with something really big, like the moon, or a dwarf planet, do it?"
As always, it depends on the speed and direction, as much as the mass. But if it happened, I suspect we'd have bigger problems to worry about than what out new orbit would be.
Or no problems at all.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThanks for taking the time to answer. I think my curiosity has been satisfied. I did a bit of reading after posting the question here and it seems to me that the simplest way to move the planet out of its orbit would be to pull it by having something really large pass by it, rather than hit it directly with something very large. If I understand correctly, that seems to be the way that scientists think that rogue planets leave their solar systems and wander around. Collisions with large bodies seem to either result in moons being formed or planets breaking up completely?, so it seems that a collision is not a "safe" method to move the planet. I'm not sure about mantaining the new orbit, rather than falling back towards the sun, as per your comment, but I'm guessing that if the Earth was pulled away from the sun by something as large as another star then it would just start falling towards that other star. Anyway to be honest I didn't need an exact calculation, more a general intuition. But thanks for the offer :)
- ColinWright 7y ago> "I'm not sure about maintaining the new orbit ..." OK, so you give it a boost. Assuming you've boosting along the orbital path, it's now travelling exactly in the same direction as it was, but faster. Its new path is an ellipse that rises to a higher peak (aphelion), slowing as it goes, but when it gets there it has lost a lot of speed. And in fact, it now doesn't have enough speed for that new, higher orbit (even though the speed for that orbit is less than the original), and because it's an ellipse that passes through that original position, it will not stay at this higher altitude, but will trace the second half of the ellipse back to the original position. The magic term is "Hohmann Transfer": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hohmann_transfer_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hohmann_transfer_orbit Again, let me know if you want more, but I see others have made similar offers so I won't be offended if you don't ask.