4 ms·
Hey Des, Sorry if my comment sounded overly critical — I'm sure you know well the frustration you can get from infographics, and simultaneously the urge to jus
by tel 16y ago
Hey Des,
Sorry if my comment sounded overly critical — I'm sure you know well the frustration you can get from infographics, and simultaneously the urge to just have everything be somehow perfect, suddenly. I want to also mention that I appreciated bringing up the Victoria Secret graphics. Sometimes it is important to lie, much like humor being the best way to tell a sad story.
Anyway, thanks for writing the article. Despite my criticisms, I'm always happy to see more arguments to whittle away abject trust in garden variety infographics.
To round out my comment, I want to mention that I really appreciated the note that there is definitely a time for confusing, artistic infographics even if they are misleading. Victoria's Secret graphics can definitely raise awareness from 0 in a hostile crowd, they also can overemphasize detils to compensate for the audience's unwillingness to consider them meaningfully.
- destraynor 16y agoHey Tel, Thanks for your reply - no worries re: sounding critical. Your points were valid. The Victorias Secret thing is something I keep reminding myself. Life is not about "usability" - the experience is more importantly. Reminds me of a Joel Spolsky quote "Usability is not everything. If usability engineers designed a nightclub, it would be clean, quiet, brightly lit, with lots of places to sit down, plenty of bartenders, menus written in 18-point sans-serif, and easy-to-find bathrooms. But nobody would be there. They would all be down the street at Coyote Ugly pouring beer on each other— - Joel Spolsky"