3 ms·
Their marriage is irrelevant because as GS have stated, they don’t have that information so they don’t take it into account. They claim they don’t know the per
by zepto 7y ago
Their marriage is irrelevant because as GS have stated, they don’t have that information so they don’t take it into account.
They claim they don’t know the person’s gender.
If they are inferring that from a first name or from other information they have then their statement is a lie.
By all means claim that GS are lying.
I’m curious to see what the result of the investigation is.
As for paying the card off in full and still not being able to spend more, indeed that doesn’t make sense for a millionaire with a high credit score. Clearly the system is not doing a good job of assessing what credit to offer her.
However the fact that she is being treated differently from her husband, who is not just a millionaire - but someone who is estimated to have >$100m, is not evidence of sexism.
Sexism would be a systematic bias.
She hasn’t provided any evidence whatsoever of that, although she has demonstrated that the system is bad at recognizing creditworthiness.
So yes - the bar for demonstrating sexism is indeed much higher, and yes, materials about how the algorithm works so implicit biases can be evaluated would necessarily be part of that.
I hope the New York Financial services investigation does get access to these materials.
My guess is that if there is a sexist bias it will take some tracking down, and that it will be a result of industry wide practices.
I think this should be reviewed across the board.
But I stand by my original comment that she hasn’t shown that there is sexism at work in her own case.
- eesmith 7y agoIf it's irrelevant than your comment "prior to their marriage" is also irrelevant, yes? Because that's what I was responding to. They don't claim to not know the person's gender. They write "Our credit decisions are based on a customer's creditworthiness and not on factors like gender, race, age, sexual orientation or any other bias prohibited by law," That is, they might know the person's gender, but not include that in the assessment. Why must their statement be a lie if there is a gender bias? There are plenty of reports of risk models which have an illegally discriminatory bias even when not designed that way. For one example https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessm... . In that case, 'Brennan said it is difficult to construct a score that doesn’t include items that can be correlated with race — such as poverty, joblessness and social marginalization. “If those are omitted from your risk assessment, accuracy goes down,” he said.' As I pointed out, there are correlations between names and gender. Almost certainly there are other correlations. A model might have trained on those factors to produce a result with an illegal gender bias, even if that wasn't deliberate. When you write "the bar for demonstrating sexism is indeed much higher", do you mean the bar for legal action, or the bar by which someone can make a public accusation? If I am black, and walk into a restaurant and refused service, then my white spouse walks in 5 minutes later and gets service, do you expect that I must remain quiet about it until I've demonstrated in a court of law that actual illegal discriminatory practice occurred? And if I go public before that's done, will you say that I haven't given you enough evidence? If yes, then in both cases, I think you are using the wrong threshold for when it's relevant and useful to go public, because doing so is part of one way to drive the resolution process. Or, if I have a child who gets a rare illness due to some heavy metal poisoning, and a local company is dumping those heavy metals into the water supply, do I need to wait until there's conclusive evidence, as for a court of law, before I go public about it? In all three cases, sure, I can be wrong. (Courts can be wrong too.) But ... so what?
- zepto 7y agoYes - it doesn’t matter whether it was prior to their marriage or not. It seems entirely possible that DHH has 20x her net worth. Perhaps that’s involved in their decision making, no? See: https://twitter.com/gsbanksupport/status/1194022629419704320?s=20 https://twitter.com/gsbanksupport/status/1194022629419704320... “In fact we do not know your gender or marital status during the Apple Card application process”. So your comments about them knowing her gender are either false, or they are lying. The analogy of your examples is invalidated by GS’s statement that they didn’t know her gender or marital status. And yes - I agree that there may be some implicit bias in a scoring algorithm somewhere along the line, or some other systemic influence. As I have said, I’d like to see the investigation look into this possibility. But “I got lower credit than my spouse”, simply is not evidence of sexism, especially if the spouse is 20x richer.
- eesmith 7y agoThe own their wealth jointly. There is no 20x different in net worth. In a community property state, any wealth made during their marriage is shared. For example, in divorce it could be split equally between the two. Again, DHH is not 20x richer than his wife. They are equally rich under the law. (Excepting any money that DHH made before the marriage, which, given that it was a long time ago, is likely a small part of that wealth.) This all came up recently during the divorce between Jeff and MacKenzie Bezos. Amazon started after their marriage, and since Washington is a community property state she was entitled to 1/2 of their shares in the divorce. It wasn't that Jeff was 10,000x richer than MacKenzie was. Please note the subtle distinction between what you wrote: "They claim they don’t know the person’s gender." and the additional qualifier GS used "during the Apple Card application process". They very likely know that she is a woman, and married. Their statement is that those aren't considered during the application process. Thus, it's possible that I am not wrong, and that they are not lying. They don't need to know one's gender or marital status to violate anti-discrimination laws, so I don't see the point of discussing that detail further.
- zepto 7y agoAll this talk about community property is well known but not relevant. It is during the application process that the credit amount is decided on and offered, and that is what the complaint about. So how is it relevant to this discussion if they find out later?