10 ms·
Nature’s survey of 6k grad students reveals the turbulence of doctoral research
- andrewl 7y agoNature published "A PhD State of Mind" in 2018, with this blurb: Recent surveys have linked academia and PhD studies to a risk of experiencing mental health issues. Despite the lack of extensive data, the negative impact of the stresses of lab life should not be underestimated, and PhD students and research trainees should be supported. It was discussed here at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19322834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19322834. Repeating a comment I made in the above discussion, here are a couple of relevant quotes from Freeman Dyson (who does not have a PhD): “Well, I think it actually is very destructive. I'm now retired, but when I was a professor here [Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton], my real job was to be a psychiatric nurse. There were all these young people who came to the institute, and my job was to be there so they could cry on my shoulder and tell me what a hard time they were having. And it was a very tough situation for these young people. They come here. They have one or two years and they're supposed to do something brilliant. They're under terrible pressure — not from us, but from them. So, actually, I've had three of them who I would say were just casualties who I'm responsible for. One of them killed himself, and two of them ended up in mental institutions. And I should've been able to take care of them, but I didn't. I blame the Ph.D. system for these tragedies. And it really does destroy people. If they weren't under that kind of pressure, they could all have been happy people doing useful stuff. Anyhow, so that's my diatribe. But I really have seen that happen."
- andrewl 7y agoAlso, The New York Times Magazine published "Lethal Chemistry at Harvard" in their November 29, 1998 issue, detailing the suicide of chemistry grad student Jason Altom: https://www.nytimes.com/1998/11/29/magazine/lethal-chemistry-at-harvard.html https://www.nytimes.com/1998/11/29/magazine/lethal-chemistry...
- VvR-Ox 7y agoI have heard something similar about a grammar school in Germany. Every 2nd year a student killed himself and also drug abuse and other things like that are more commonplace there compared to other types of schools in the city. It seems that many similar institutions cannot cope with the development of young people and then the pressure rises until some of them see no other choice but to end this or try to escape. Also mental health problems seem to increase in young people. Somehow I think they should get more attention from really skilled people with social skills and also the education system(s) need to change to allow them to grow up before putting too much pressure on them.
- pm90 7y agoI think you make a very good point in your last statement. The reason for encouraging young people to succeed within institutional frameworks can be easily explained as a direct outcome of the needs of modern states to churn out skilled people for “The betterment of the Nation”. Schools were originally meant to train the population in skills that would greatly assist them as soldiers or workers in a factory. Life expectancies were different then and so were social conventions around eg marriage. Today, most nations are at peace and life expectancy is generally large and fertility rates and marriage are declining. This means that there isn’t the urgent need as it was then to train early. Institutions should be changed with these new circumstances in mind.
- code_code 7y agoI forget the name of the other famous physicist (not Dyson) who said it, but the quote was: "I've seen more [persons] destroyed by Physics than by drugs". I don't regret my Ph.D., but I still remember the monotone voice in which I defended my dissertation. Listen to advice here. Powerlessness is quite something to experience when one is (has been) locked in for years.
- ksey3 7y agoSometimes I think PhD's should be awarded to Groups or atleast Pairs of researchers. Let the group find each other and defend a thesis. If the group breaks apart they loose their certification of expertise. And can reform and reprove it. Those who want to do things alone can, ofcourse do things the old way. This would reduce the the unrealistic expectations on some folk who work better in groups, while allowing them to hone whatever skills they bring to the table. Groups basically compensate for each others limitations and in the modern highly competitive world, with it's time/resource constraints and complex problems certifying individual expertise is looking over rated.
- refurb 7y agoOne of the main goals of a PhD is educating an individual so they can independently direct a research program. Awarding PhDs to pairs of people goes directly against that.
- tajd 7y agoPhDs are fundamentally not about a team effort. They are about recognising a single persons ability to produce and communicate novel research in a highly specific area. Unrealistic expectations are as much a part of this process as they are anything else.
- _emacsomancer_ 7y agoIt happens occasionally: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Stokhof https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Stokhof
- lilott8 7y agoMy advisor pseudo follows this. He does his best to bring in pairs of students that will be on _similar_ topics. (of course they are both responsible for their independent research and thesis). That way they can struggle together and find their way, it helps lesson the burden he has as idea generation now is covered and "getting stuck" is less worrisome as you are stuck with someone. As the students grow, they separate into their own thesis but the great part is they tend to still collaborate with their peer, so even by thesis end, both know each other's thesis pretty well.
- noobermin 7y agoTbh I'm tired of the Nature articles about this. When is something going to change?
- knzhou 7y agoIt will not change as long as the laws of supply and demand continue to hold. Science funding has been continuously rising at an incredible pace for the last century, causing the field to grow by nearly two orders of magnitude. But we are always strapped for cash because we can always instantly grow to carrying capacity for the funding, and that’s because a single professor can have upwards of 25 students throughout their career, in some fields 100. If we weren’t at carrying capacity, nobody would have to put up with bad advisors and low pay. But we will always be at carrying capacity. Funding could grow by 10x tomorrow and we would be right back in the same position in 20 years.
- asdff 7y agoIt's good we have an educate workforce ready to absorb increases in research funding imo. However, dealing with abusive advisors and low pay isn't going to change with research funding. That's the individual school's prerogative to set that stipend. Most of them aren't even close to the NSF. Schools definitely have the funding to bump stipends to 3x(market rate apartment), but they don't. There's always money in the banana stand (endowment/football).
- musicale 7y agoWhen the incentives change. Which means probably not in the next few decades. Or perhaps if there is enough bad publicity and/or lawsuits by parents/families of students who died from suicide, and/or if enough grad students unionize and take action. Universities hate bad publicity. It's one of the few forms of leverage against them.
- eli_gottlieb 7y agoWhen we unionize.
- 1_over_n 7y agoI worked in an animal lab on masters research that required strict 12/12 light cycles. 12 hours bright white, 12 hours red light (circadian rhythms impacted the study design). No windows and no support from post doc or supervisors (both had different serious health problems). I'm quite an upbeat person so it was fine short term, it did put me off academia and purusing a PhD though. Good decision in retrospect and after staying in contact with my peers who have not learned much new and have in my opinion over-specialised.
- throwaway_shame 7y agoI am currently a master's student and about to start PhD in one of the top AI labs. I already feel mentally exhausted with all the indirect pressure tactics my supervisor uses like not responding to emails, withholding stipend for several months and so on. It's a disaster and I never imagined myself in this situation. I hope things change soon.
- musicale 7y agoThis isn't going to change. You should do everything in your power to get a better supervisor, particularly for your dissertation research. You're early enough in the process that starting a new project, or modifying your current project, is completely worth it to get a better supervisor who actually supports you and will help you graduate. Talk to other grad students to see what they think of their advisors. Also you should try to find other faculty (and possibly postdocs) to advise you who aren't your supervisor if at all possible, and try to form an informal group of grad students to meet periodically to discuss research and grad life in general. And remember it is a marathon not a race, so overworking is usually unproductive unless you are up against a strict paper deadline (even then it's unproductive but may be worth it in the short run.)
- pelario 7y agoThis sound advice. I cannot emphasize enough how important is the supervisor in the PhD experience, IMO, the most relevant factor. So if this is the treatment you get even before starting... I would also say, yes, look for another place.
- montalbano 7y agoI just finished my PhD. My first half was with a supervisor similar to what OP described. Fortunately I was able to transfer halfway through to a much better supervisor. I have seen both sides, having a good supervisor makes a massive difference. Even so, now that I am finished, the emotional drain of the first two years and lack of time to properly recover has left me completely BURNT OUT. OP, please take the advice of musicale, it is EXACTLY RIGHT. I am a little dissapointed to find many comments here putting the responsibility on the (prospective) PhD student. I'm sure this is the case sometimes. In my case I was absolutely happy doing independent research at all times in my life apart from with this horrendous supervisor who, at all turns, made it difficult to do good science.
- Traubenfuchs 7y agoThe disastrous impact of PhD's on their authors health is already well known. The sad reality of the scientific publication, funding and politics game rat race is well known. Whether a PhD is a good idea, financially or economically, is debated. Why do people who are not 100% sure they want to do a PhD and know what it means continue to start one? (And how do we stop them? -That's the real question.)
- helpPeople 7y agoIt's an indicator of intelligence. Although I'm glad to have learned at work, that a PhD is not the only way to showcase this.
- asdff 7y agoYou can be absolutely certain you want to do a PhD and still end up with an abusive advisor. Certainty doesn't need to have anything to do with the state of your mental health with your PhD. What we should be stopping is these tenured advisors who literally get away with screaming at their students. A PhD should be what you make of it. If you want to work for 3 hours a day and have it take 8+ years, then so be it. Sometimes you do need to do that if you have dependents, for instance. You can always secure your own funding and/or TA. But it shouldn't be an excuse for a boss to squeeze unlimited hours out of you for less than the price of an hourly technician.
- ImaCake 7y agoI was once inside the research bubble but fell out when I quit from burn out. I have no regrets and have had wonderful and colourful jobs in the three years since. But I still dabble in research and have friends doing PhDs and post-docs. Honestly, what I see is that every single person in research is unhappy in some way. The degree varies, but they all struggle at least a little more because of their jobs.
- yodsanklai 7y ago> Honestly, what I see is that every single person in research is unhappy in some way Would they be happier doing a different job? The grass is always greener...
- ImaCake 7y agoA good counter yes. I can only vouch for my own health improvements, but a lot of what makes a PhD bad for mental health is just that it is effectively a miserable and badly paid job.
- mikorym 7y agoI started to work instead of doing a PhD and I think it was a good decision. The sad part is having less time and progressing more slowly with research (outside of one's job, whatever it may be) but maybe it's better than not having a job and also progressing slowly doing a PhD full time. As an aside, if you have a clear research interest already (which many PhD naturally take a long time to find) then I don't think it matters that much anymore whether you have the actual qualification. In Mathematics it could be easier to go the direct path to research than in Biology, though. Two papers can these days even be converted to a PhD with minimal additional work.
- helpPeople 7y agoI study on my own and present it on my website, no paywall or subscription. I do what I want, rather than what a professor tells me. I've been featured on some top websites. My point is, you don't need academia necessarily. And after meeting PhD grads, I'm not sure I believe in the positive association with intelligence and accomplishments.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoReally true. We need more examples of people completing PhDs in 1-2 years because they've already done the research and written most of the thesis. It's totally possible.
- ISL 7y agoThat misses the learning process in a PhD program. A PhD is not just the thesis work, it is also the education and mentorship that is generally necessary to become an expert in both a broad field and a specialty.
- pergadad 7y agoWhy shouldn't it be easy(ier) to get the PhD when you've already worked and published for 10 years in the field?
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThat one conversation I had in the engineering building parking lot, with that one guy that I don't even remember who he was... he persuaded me that going into grad school in physics, chasing the unified field theory, wasn't a useful use of my life. Seeing all this makes me very grateful for that conversation. Thank you, whoever you were.