3 ms·
Ah: http://redis.io/commands/multi http://redis.io/commands/multi. So the problem with this approach is that there are no consistent reads. If I say: MULTI
by IgorPartola 16y ago
Ah: http://redis.io/commands/multi http://redis.io/commands/multi. So the problem with this approach is that there are no consistent reads. If I say:
MULTI
get foo # Returns 'abc'
set foo 'abcd' # (as in application code said foo += 'd')
EXEC
while another process sets foo to 'xyz' between my get and set, I just overwrote that value. No serializable transactions.
- lukesandberg 16y agoim not exactly sure about that but i know that at least for integers there are atomic update commands and that for strings there are atomic append commands. so for this you would really just want to do: APPEND foo d or for more complex situations you could do use WATCH instead of MULTI so that you can get the intermediate results. so for your example: WATCH foo GET foo ->value //calculate new_value MULTI SET foo new_value EXEC now if at any other operation (not part of this connection) modifies foo then the transaction will be aborted. GET foo -> value //application logic to update value GETSET foo new_value ->prev then prev will contain the value of foo at the time it was set, so you can then use application logic to roll back or redo the transaction
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- liuliu 16y agoRedis is single-thread one-process program. Since the execution only happens when EXEC command received, such scenario cannot exist.
- antirez 16y agoMULTI/EXEC is completely atomic and transactional. You can perform just writes inside the block. If you want atomicity with reads in the middle, you need to use WATCH/MULTI/EXEC that uses an optimistic locking algorithm.
- IgorPartola 16y agoAh, that makes sense. I imagine allowing atomic reads without WATCH would complicate the code quite a bit.
- antirez 16y agoIndeed, not very Redis-ish :) With WATCH is very easy. WATCH this keys. Perform your reads. Prepare to write in a transaction. If at least one key was modified in the meantime the transaction will fail.
- x09 16y agoSalvatore, you do realize that now you need to put a Klashnikov on the new Redis logo? :p