4 ms·
At our company if the HR goes through your social media, and finds any evidence you may be socially activist or virtue signaling or otherwise very loudly procla
by xwdv 7y ago
At our company if the HR goes through your social media, and finds any evidence you may be socially activist or virtue signaling or otherwise very loudly proclaiming your disapproval of something some entity is doing, you will not be hired. You will not even get a call back. You will be labeled as a potential troublemaker (not in the good way) and be placed on the blacklist.
- purplezooey 7y agoVery not cool
- inferiorhuman 7y agoAnd what if you do not give HR access to your social media?
- xwdv 7y agoLet’s just say you can’t stop someone with administrative privileges.
- duxup 7y agoAdministrative privileges .... to what? There's no single social media administrative privilege across platforms that I'm aware of.
- javagram 7y agoIf you’re already keeping your social media protected/private, that seems like a pretty good sign that you’re not a political troublemaker or activist. Private social media accounts don’t have virality or reach. I keep my own twitter and facebook private because I have no interest in accidentally igniting a feeding frenzy if I post something wrong on social media. But it’s equally true that if I wanted to make a fuss about something at my employer or elsewhere, my posts will go nowhere since only a small number of people can see or access them.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoIf you’re already keeping your social media protected/private, that seems like a pretty good sign that you’re not a political troublemaker or activist. How do you figure that? I keep most of my social media stuff private but I would happily participate in, for instance, a unionization campaign and I will vocally support the sorts of folks that people like Damore seek to condemn.
- javagram 7y agoI guess it depends on your definition of activist. When I hear that, I think of someone like prominent tech twitter personalities who are employed at places like google/github and like to get into flame wars on twitter and so on. I assumed that’s what the person was talking about as well. I think there are plenty of people who might sign onto a union election or unionization at work who aren’t social media bomb throwers. I’d consider it myself if it came up and were convinced it would be good for me as an employee. I don’t think an employer looking through public social feeds would be very effective in screening that out, especially in technology where the majority of employees are openly liberal and Democrat in my experience.
- repolfx 7y agoDamore didn't condemn anyone, that's just a smear attack.
- inferiorhuman 7y ago
- Thorrez 7y agoSome people like having public Twitter accounts. Or public Hacker News accounts.
- driverdan 7y agoWhich company? Let us know so we can avoid it.
- thephyber 7y agoSounds like a recipe for an aggressively mediocre company. Relevant EconTalk podcast episode[1] about companies with "loose cultures" and others with "tight cultures". Some people and some industries tend to lean towards a "loose" or "tight" culture and it's interesting to hear about M&As where one type swallows the other and the inevitable indigestion happens. I'm not sure why you are being downvoted. I read your comment simply as a statement of fact, not a preference for/against that policy. [1] https://www.econtalk.org/michele-gelfand-on-rule-makers-rule-breakers/ https://www.econtalk.org/michele-gelfand-on-rule-makers-rule...
- askafriend 7y agoAll this does is ensure only mediocre people are hired. What you described is how you might hire for McDonald’s, not a high growth company that is building something massive/valuable. I work with a group of the most talented people in the world at what they do and 0 of them would want to work in an environment you describe. In fact they won’t even consider a company remotely like what you describe.
- xwdv 7y agoDoesn’t matter. We turn mediocre generalists into skilled specialists with niche knowledge of different domains within a year. And because the things we teach them don’t have much application outside the company they are very loyal. Talented people with social activism fantasies are overrated. They can’t always be trusted to simply do what you tell them. They think their talents give them leverage, and that if they see anything they deem improper, they have a responsibility to resist it.
- Jonnax 7y agoSo from what you've said, your company teaches their employees to be worthless in the job marketplace, thus having lower earning potential. But also your firm engages in practices that could be viewed as morally dubious that HR activily screens out people that might have any kind of social media presence. Which sounds like a fear of whistleblowers more than anything. "They can’t always be trusted to simply do what you tell them." Such a telling phrase.
- askafriend 7y agoFrankly this sounds like a total disaster of a company. I don’t want to work with mediocre people who end up stuck in jobs they hate. Real talent does give people leverage. What you’re describing is not talent - it’s dubious/ exploitative/desperate management practices combined with a funnel of people who don’t know better. Literally no genuinely talented engineer would stay in a job like the one you describe - it just wouldn’t make sense. Skills especially are very fungible. I can apply to work at Google tomorrow without knowing their tech stack at all, get an offer, and pull down $500k+ a year. Does your company’s ARR even touch $50m?