11 ms·
> The documents concerned a mandatory tool that was recently installed on the Google Chrome browser on workers’ computers, the employees said. In October, some
by skissane 7y ago
> The documents concerned a mandatory tool that was recently installed on the Google Chrome browser on workers’ computers, the employees said. In October, some Google employees raised concerns that the Chrome extension was an internal surveillance tool designed to monitor their attempts to organize protests. It would automatically report staffers who create a calendar event with more than 10 rooms or 100 participants, according to an employee memo that outlined concerns about the tool
From a technical viewpoint, I don't get this. Why create a Chrome extension to monitor usage of Google Calendar? Doesn't Google Calendar have an API they could use to do this on the server-side instead? (And if it doesn't, maybe they should add the necessary features to their API to enable this, and doing that might then benefit their customers and their partner ecosystem.)
- swiley 7y agoThe monitors probably (correctly) aren’t authorized to use the API.
- bonesss 7y agoThe API is made to make automation around calendaring tasks easy. You can pull up appointments, see who booked them, and manage their state. (https://developers.google.com/calendar/overview https://developers.google.com/calendar/overview) Tracking activity in activity planning software isn't quite as nefarious as looking at peoples emails. Pulling up the meeting bookers boss and sending an email to them & legal is pretty bog standard integration work. As stated, I can't see any requirement for a client-side footprint...
- ajross 7y agoAn extension is the kind of random IT junk companies push all the time. Pushing surveillance into the server side of a core product is rather more heavy an operation.
- mindslight 7y agoBut Google's core business is surveillance. Implementing it server-side could make it available as a GSuite feature. Bonus points for passing it through an opaque ML step for plausible deniability. "The 'culture fit' 'algorithm' determined that you hurt team cohesion".
- Normal_gaussian 7y agoMaking it a prod ready feature would take weeks, a pile of money, and dozens of staff who may object and are in a position to do something about it. Making a single use extension takes an hour or three by a contractor who won't object. Its trivial enough that the whole thing could be built using a bottom of the barrel freelancer site with a high success rate.
- mindslight 7y agoYeah, and Eric Schmidt could have simply taken a digital camera into a public restroom, snapped some pictures over the stall walls, and been satiated. Yet here we are.
- robbya 7y agoInstalling an extension to monitor employee use of a company computer is legal and generally accepted behavior. If the Google calendar is for a personal gmail account, then accessing the calendar details server side is a huge privacy breach.
- usr1106 7y ago> Installing an extension to monitor employee use of a company computer is legal and generally accepted behavior. Legal and generally accepted in US jurisdiction. In Germany that would require approval by employee representatives, unlikely to happen in any bigger company. In Finland a somewhat related and highly controversive law was introduced many years ago that it would be legal if registered with data protection authorities. Something like 3 companies registered in a decade. Maybe some did it without registering, but generally this is not deemed clearly acceptable practice.
- DeckOfSardines 7y agoCan you expand on this point? I wasn't sure if your point was that this might hinder Google expanding in other countries or if you were just taking issue with the phrasing.
- usr1106 7y agoMy point was just to show that legal systems differ and the balance between employer and employee rights can vary. Google has a big data center in Finland. IIRC they stopped their plans for a Berlin lab after visible anti-Google protests in the neighborhood, but I'm sure they have employees somewhere in Germany. International companies just follow local legislation and practices and there is no problem (most of the time at least, there are examples of failure like Walmart trying to expand to Germany with too much of an American management style and eventually giving up).
- jeltz 7y agoGoogle already have expanded to plenty of countries, and presumably in some of them this kind of monitoring would be illegal.
- thrower123 7y agoTen rooms or a hundred attendees seems like the kind of event that shouldn't be any kind of problem if it were flagged; presumably that's some kind of company sanctioned event. If it's not, what in the flipping hell are you doing using company property and resources to organize it? I understand that people mix their personal and corporate identities together shamelessly, but that just seems like shockingly poor opsec.
- loopz 7y agoKinda hard when you work in a huge center owned by the same corporation.
- oh_sigh 7y agoMaybe it's to prevent calendar spam, either inadvertently or through abuse?
- goatinaboat 7y agoWhy create a Chrome extension to monitor usage of Google Calendar? Obviously for the “chilling effect”. Really rubbing it in the employee’s faces that they’re being surveilled.
- angry_octet 7y agoRemember that those who decided calendar monitoring was the right approach are idiots. They don't think beyond what they intend to happen.
- jiveturkey 7y agocan't understand why you're being downvoted. the chilling effect is indeed the obvious reason.
- mywacaday 7y agoI sign into chrome at work and home and my extensions are synced, so was this extension installed on personal devices?
- 3xblah 7y agoPerhaps by doing the monitoring client-side they can get reports both on successful attempts to create a calendar event as well as unsuccessful attempts to create a calendar event. For example, even if the browser for some reason cannot connect to the server and no event is actually created, perhaps the extension still reports on the "attempt" to create an event.
- brown9-2 7y agoI don’t think people are considering enough that the people who raised the concerns could simply be wrong. Note that Google didn’t need an extension to know which employees were tracking other employee’s calendars.