4 ms·
The well regulated militia is subject to regulation.
by Spooky23 7y ago
The well regulated militia is subject to regulation.
- jakeogh 7y agoHeller vs DC: https://s3.amazonaws.com/oyez.case-media.ogg/case_data/2007/07-290/20080626o_07-290.ogg https://s3.amazonaws.com/oyez.case-media.ogg/case_data/2007/...
- arcticbull 7y agoI'd appreciate a summary of this 23 minute long audio recording ;)
- jakeogh 7y agoI added the title, but I wouldnt do it justice, Scalia gives a fantastic overview of what the militia is in the first few minutes.
- MaulingMonkey 7y agoIt's a summary of the court's opinion and reasoning (and dissenting opinion) in the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_v._Heller https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_v._Heller supreme court case, as to the constitutionality of DC's handgun restrictions at the time, in light of the second amendment. Worth a listen if you've any interest in how we regulate gun ownership, IMO. If you use javascriptlets like: javascript:document.getElementsByTagName("video")[0].playbackRate=2 This actually works in chrome, to speed up the audio playback, if you're short on time.
- amanaplanacanal 7y agoYou can skip the recording and read the ruling itself. It is fairly short and there is nothing in it that is difficult to understand.
- randyrand 7y agoWhen was this?
- MaulingMonkey 7y agoI assume shortly after the supreme court vote on this case - June 26th, 2008. Perhaps the same day.
- droithomme 7y agoIn colonial era English language, well regulated refers to something being properly functioning, ie in working order. It has nothing to do with regulations.
- pmiller2 7y agoMore specifically, "regulated" means something like "trained."
- Spooky23 7y agoQ: How were colonial era soldiers trained? A: Soldiers were trained to follow rules (aka regulations) and obey. Line up shoulder to shoulder and fire 3-5 volleys a minute in a prescribed manner. A rabble would get 1-2 off and die.
- kube-system 7y agoYes, that's organizational discipline, not legislative decree.
- wan23 7y agoRegulations are the means by which you make something be regulated. The relationship between these words hasn't changed. https://www.etymonline.com/word/regulate https://www.etymonline.com/word/regulate
- Pyxl101 7y agoThe phrase "well-regulated" is an idiom that means something like "working as expected, calibrated correctly, normal, regular". You can't interpret an idiom literally based solely on the words that it's made from - idioms have their own independent meaning. The following source gives examples from the Oxford English Dictionary of how the idiom was used from 1709 through 1894, demonstrating how the idiom 'well-regulated' has meaning beyond 'regulations' i.e. laws. https://www.constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm https://www.constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm > 1709: "If a liberal Education has formed in us well-regulated Appetites and worthy Inclinations." > 1714: "The practice of all well-regulated courts of justice in the world." > 1812: "The equation of time ... is the adjustment of the difference of time as shown by a well-regulated clock and a true sun dial." > 1848: "A remissness for which I am sure every well-regulated person will blame the Mayor." > 1862: "It appeared to her well-regulated mind, like a clandestine proceeding." > 1894: "The newspaper, a never wanting adjunct to every well-regulated American embryo city." The sense of the term above is something like 'normal', 'well-ordered', 'regular'. Indeed the word 'regular' also shares the same origin as the word 'regulations', yet its common meanings are unrelated to the concept of regulations. Parsing the 2nd Amendment, the US Supreme Court wrote that "the adjective “well-regulated” implies nothing more than the imposition of proper discipline and training", and elaborated (quoting another scholar, Thomas Cooley): > The meaning of the provision undoubtedly is, that the people, from whom the militia must be taken, shall have the right to keep and bear arms; and they need no permission or regulation of law for the purpose. But this enables government to have a well-regulated militia; for to bear arms implies something more than the mere keeping; it implies the learning to handle and use them in a way that makes those who keep them ready for their efficient use; in other words, it implies the right to meet for voluntary discipline in arms, observing in doing so the laws of public order.” https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/#tab-opinion-1962738 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/#tab-opi... The phrase "a well-regulated militia" in this context consequently means a militia that's learned, proficient, and effective in firearm use. In any case, what we're discussing is the preface of the amendment, which announces a purpose for the amendment and does not limit it. As the court wrote: > The Second Amendment is naturally divided into two parts: its prefatory clause and its operative clause. The former does not limit the latter grammatically, but rather announces a purpose. The Amendment could be rephrased, “Because a well regulated Militia is necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.”
- User23 7y agoAnd every citizen and immigrant who intends to become a citizen man (and women in the Guard) at least 17 years of age and under 45 is a member of the Militia of the United States[1]. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/246 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/246
- ineedasername 7y agoBut for the purpose of militia in this context and therefore that of the 2nd amendment, the power of Congress over the militia is deemed "unlimited" [0]. As such, regulating it's use of arms would be well within it's remit. [0] https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/article-1/58-the-militia-clauses.html https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/article-1/58-the-mili...
- TimTheTinker 7y ago... as long as such regulation does not infringe the right of the people to keep or bear arms for all the purposes envisioned by the constitutional framers. Wikipedia has an excellent reference on this. See the "Experience in America prior to the U.S. Constitution" section: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Amendment_to_the_Unit...
- mrmonkeyman 7y agoGood luck fighting carriers and strategic bombers with your militia. Also, what's the use of a militia being recognized and, wow, regulated by the very government they are designed to oppose if push comes to shove.
- ineedasername 7y agoThe purposes of the framers appears to be a well regulated militia, and that militia subject to "unlimited" control by congress. I agree this would mean congress could not dismantle or subvert the purpose of the militia, but having tight controls over the weaponry at their disposal when not in a state of current or imminent battle would not seem to so undermine it. After all, even the professional military have much, much more tightly controlled access to & tracking of firearms than is imposed in civil society. It is hard to credit an argument that would say militia could not reasonably & constitutionally mirror those same controls.
- Pyxl101 7y agoThat clause simply provides one important reason why "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed". It's not a limitation or restriction on that right. For more an extensive deep-dive on the meaning of this amendment, see District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 570 (2008): https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/#tab-opinion-1962738 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/#tab-opi... > ... the Second Amendment’s prefatory clause announces the purpose for which the right was codified: to prevent elimination of the militia. The prefatory clause does not suggest that preserving the militia was the only reason Americans valued the ancient right; most undoubtedly thought it even more important for self-defense and hunting. But the threat that the new Federal Government would destroy the citizens’ militia by taking away their arms was the reason that right—unlike some other English rights—was codified in a written Constitution. ... > Besides ignoring the historical reality that the Second Amendment was not intended to lay down a “novel principl[e]” but rather codified a right “inherited from our English ancestors,” Robertson v. Baldwin, 165 U. S. 275, 281 (1897), petitioners’ interpretation does not even achieve the narrower purpose that prompted codification of the right. If, as they believe, the Second Amendment right is no more than the right to keep and use weapons as a member of an organized militia — if, that is, the organized militia is the sole institutional beneficiary of the Second Amendment’s guarantee — it does not assure the existence of a “citizens’ militia” as a safeguard against tyranny ... > Every late-19th-century legal scholar that we have read interpreted the Second Amendment to secure an individual right unconnected with militia service. The most famous was the judge and professor Thomas Cooley, who wrote a massively popular 1868 Treatise on Constitutional Limitations. Concerning the Second Amendment it said: (...) > “It might be supposed from the phraseology of this provision that the right to keep and bear arms was only guaranteed to the militia; but this would be an interpretation not warranted by the intent. The militia, as has been elsewhere explained, consists of those persons who, under the law, are liable to the performance of military duty, and are officered and enrolled for service when called upon. (...) The meaning of the provision undoubtedly is, that the people, from whom the militia must be taken, shall have the right to keep and bear arms; and they need no permission or regulation of law for the purpose. But this enables government to have a well-regulated militia; for to bear arms implies something more than the mere keeping; it implies the learning to handle and use them in a way that makes those who keep them ready for their efficient use; in other words, it implies the right to meet for voluntary discipline in arms, observing in doing so the laws of public order.”
- golemotron 7y agoIn the 1700s, the word "regulated" meant "in good working order." It did not have the association with law that we have now. You can look into the history, but if you don't care to, consider that "regulations" (as we've described them over the past few centuries) are a form of law found in modern bureaucracies.