4 ms·
I don't think that is true in practice It is true in practice. One example: the children of illegal immigrants are legally entitled to public education, even
by reaperducer 7y ago
I don't think that is true in practice
It is true in practice.
One example: the children of illegal immigrants are legally entitled to public education, even though they aren't citizens.
- elil17 7y agoThis gets a couple things wrong: 1) People who aren’t citizens are still entitled to public education. Many green card holders go to US public schools, for instance 2) Anyone born on US soil is a US citizen regardless of their parents immigration status
- jessaustin 7y agoClearly parent is not talking about children born in USA, so your second point is not relevant. Your first point is just a restatement of parent.
- adiM 7y agoThe grant-parent said "children of _illegal_ immigrants" and the parent is talking about "children of _Green card holders_". Green card holders are those who have immigrated legally.
- jessaustin 7y agoThe question of the thread is to what extent non-citizens have particular rights. Parents cite two distinct yet substantially similar groups of non-citizens (one presumes that children don't have much agency with respect to the circumstances of their immigration). Both examples argue in the same direction on the question of the thread, so why does this distinction matter?
- leereeves 7y agoIs the first point a constitutional issue? I don't recall the constitution guaranteeing anyone a public education.
- dragonwriter 7y agoIt doesn't require public education, but it restricts discrimination if it is provided by the state, as all states do. So, yes, it is a Constitutional issue.
- leereeves 7y agoWhich part of rhe Constitution forbids discrimination based on citizenship status?
- dragonwriter 7y agoNo part of the Constitution entirely forbids discrimination on any basis, but the part that is held to limit state discrimination on that basis is—as limits state discrimination on every basis—the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment.
- torstenvl 7y agoThe equal protection clause applies to citizenship status. The key case on citizenship discrimination and public education is Plyler v. Doe, 457 U.S. 202 (1982) available at https://www.uscourts.gov/educational-resources/educational-activities/access-education-rule-law https://www.uscourts.gov/educational-resources/educational-a...
- selimthegrim 7y agoEven foreign diplomats' kids?
- xyzzyz 7y agoOnly because the Supreme Court decided in 5-to-4 decision that the states don't have a "substantial state interest" that would allow them to deny it. See Plyler v. Doe. Which is to say, the constitutional rights of non-citizens are hardly as obvious as they are for citizens.
- arcticbull 7y agoThis follows logically, in my opinion, from the idea that the federal government is solely responsible for matters of immigration law. You don't want to create a patchwork of different rules in different states based on presence granted and retracted at the sole discretion of the federal government. Once you're on US soil, you're largely treated the same as anyone else on US soil (or at least through the same framework), and that makes sense. If you should be removed, that's up to the Feds. To the extent you're not, you should be treated consistently. You are of course correct that the rules do not apply evenly for immigrants and nonimmigrants, especially since nonimmigrants convicted of a crime are largely seen out as soon as their sentence is served. The same isn't true of immigrants. Mostly.
- xyzzyz 7y agoThis follows logically, in my opinion, from the idea that the federal government is solely responsible for matters of immigration law. This argument makes sense, but I think it proves too much: states already have plenty of laws that restrict certain rights or privileges to citizens only. Your argument, as I understand it, is that since immigration status is a matter of federal law, states cannot deny a right (to K-12 education) on the basis of immigration status -- but it is commonly accepted that they can and do deny such a right in other circumstances, e.g. to serve as a police officer, for example, which I'm quite sure state laws deny to illegal immigrants. are largely seen out as soon as their sentence is served What do you mean by "seen out", exactly?
- arcticbull 7y ago> What do you mean by "seen out", exactly? Committing a crime of moral turpitude as a non-immigrant (and even some green card holders) makes you eligible for deportation. [1] [1] https://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/us-immigration/legal-reasons-immigrant-may-be-deported.html https://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/us-immigration/legal-re...
- Rebelgecko 7y agoI disagree that it is true in practice, because the government can get away with claiming that not treating everyone on US soil equally is OK in the interest of public safety. https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-court-guns-immigrants-20190108-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-court-guns-immi...
- logfromblammo 7y agoIt's true in practice in a lot of places. In some places, persons without ironclad immigration status can be hassled out of enjoying public services with spitefully racist levels of bureaucratic process. It is similar to how same-sex marriages were denied after being declared legal by county clerks that refused to issue the documents that record their marriage publicly. The kids aren't denied public education, per se, but they certainly cannot get the same education experience as citizens and legal residents get. No electives. No extracurriculars. No field trips. No cafeteria payment accounts. All those things require the proper forms, and proof of residency, you see. As a bonus (malus?), the very same malicious process can be used against kids of homeless parents.