4 ms·
SEC Wins Jury Trial in Layering, Manipulative Trading Case
- vxxzy 7y agoHow does this differ from HFTs flooding the order book and then cancelling?
- NovemberWhiskey 7y agoLeaving aside "flooding the order book"; the primary difference is that the HFT orders are made in good faith with intent to trade at the order price based on the current market. Layering and spoofing are not done in good faith: there is never any intent to trade, just to convey a false appearance of market demand.
- jjtheblunt 7y agoThat's a grey area, I believe, because such a pattern might occur legitimately though would also arise from calculated manipulation. Perhaps they were unable to find otherwise legitimate trades from the traders ?
- Traster 7y agoWhat 'HF'T teams do is high frequency trading, or rather low latency trading. You put offers in the book you feel comfortable trading at, and you are happy if you trade at that price. If the market price stays static they pick up the spread on average. However, the reason they are so tight in the order book, is because if the market moves they're very quick to pull their offers and bids and move to a new price. HFT companies are providing liquidity in that situation. As long as you place a single order, it will get fulfilled. So to be clear, the HFT firm that places orders in the market want to trade those offers. They're comfortable placing those orders more competitively than your average punter because they can respond to market moving events quicker. Layering and spoofing is something different - you're placing orders in order to make people think you want to trade, but you don't. It's like asking me what's the difference between Al Gore offering you money to tackle climate change and a climate change denier offering you money to tackle climate change? Well one of them is clearly lying.
- perspective1 7y agoHFTs scale their operation across a huge population of securities. These Ukranians apparently targeted just a handful.
- hermitdev 7y agoHFT market makers are often responding to an IOI (Indication of Interest) which an exchange will broadcast when they have orders on the book. A responder that's interested in the trade will typically respond with an IOC (Immediate or Cancel) order. The order book is handled on FIFO (First-in, First-out) fulfillment method. If the IOC order isn't filled/partially filled, it is immediately cancelled. This is standard practice and encouraged by exchanges of their market makers. Spoofing can be done many ways, but it's usually something like submitting a day order at an unreasonable price, then cancelling, say 10ms later. Of course, reality is a bit more nuanced than that. Source: I've worked in IT in Finance my entire career and have often dealt with SEC/FINRA/FBI requests for order history, and identifying which of our client(s) made the orders. Typically for specific tickers on specific dates, but sometimes for all tickers on specific dates, or for specific tickers for several years. Last I had to run these reports, it was for a small dark pool (like an exchange with unpublished prices). We typically had 10s of millions of orders a day. Quite a bit smaller than an HFT firm will be handling, but still quite a bit of data to work with and have to hand over on DVDs.
- raviolo 7y agoHFTs quote in a given symbol, often derivative e.g. “AMZN 2000 strike call option” based on market in another symbol, often outright e.g. “AMZN stock“. They are willing and happy to trade at prices quoted while market in AMZN remains what it is. Once it moves, they re-price their quotes in option(s). Their quote sizes are usually pretty small. Spoofers put out orders without intention to trade. In fact, usually they would be horrified if their entire order trades. Their order price is not based on another market; their only intention is to impact prices in the book where they put the spoofing order. To achieve that, they often use disproportionately large order sizes, such as posting quantity 1000 where most other orders are between 1 and 20. Often they keep “applying the pressure” on the market by modifying the large spoofing order multiple times towards the market - moving the sell order lower and buy order higher - not as a response to changing market conditions in some other instrument but with the sole intention of impacting the price in the book in question.
- raviolo 7y agoThis is great but what jurisdiction does SEC have over Ukrainian entity? Sounds a bit like robo-callers with gozilian in fines issued and near zero collected.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoInteracting with the US banking system is necessary for trading on US stock exchanges, which means that they can be essentially banned from the US banking system on pain of getting all their money seized.
- anonu 7y agoWhat jurisdiction does the US have to nab Somali pirates off a skiff off the coast of Africa and bring them to trial in NYC? What jurisdiction does the US have to kill terrorists on foreign soil? Probably a lot less jurisdiction than people mucking about in US markets...
- anonu 7y agoI'm sure Matt Levine will have something interesting to say about this one! Here's the original SEC complaint from March 2017: https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2017/comp-pr2017-63.pdf https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2017/comp-pr2017-6... First thought: settle with the SEC. Don't fight it. Second thought: and a quick perusal of the original complaint finds multiple examples: if you're going to do something illegal don't write about your illegal activities in an email. Let alone explain "layering works like this..." Third thought: I'm surprised it took this long to get these guys. There were a few spoof related cases back in 2016... Famously the London spoofer with s&p futures. This one didn't show up until 2017... And then took almost 3 years through a jury trial.
- bertjk 7y agoHe has recently written about something similar: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-10-24/we-had-been-hoping-to-get-paid https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-10-24/we-had... I personally don't see the crime here though. What does it mean to place orders you don't intend to execute? (It is not like they have some way of reneging on the transaction if their bid/offer gets hit.) And in the manipulation of prices, why would simply flashing new non-executing orders on the screen cause market makers to change their prices? Don't the market makers have some responsibility / agency around deciding what to price something at?
- anonu 7y ago1. You cannot place orders for the sake of placing an order. It must be placed with the intention of getting filled. I'm summarizing here but this is generally the law. 2. Placing orders causes prices to move. This is how the markets work. So if you do #1 with the intention of #2, that's market manipulation.
- Traster 7y agoMarket makers decide a fair value for a product, decide the volatility and therefore quote a bid/ask spread. One important input into that decision is what other players in the market are willing to trade at. If there's a huge volume offering to buy at 10, I can buy at 11 safe in the knowledge that generally I can offload that at 10 if things don't go well. Remember, market makers aren't making a profit on every trade, they're making a profit over many trades by taking on risk. Sometimes the market will genuinely move due to outside news and they'll take losses in those cases. They don't know they're going to be able to sell their position for a profit, they just know if they quote correctly that they can extract a premium for taking on that risk (and then alpha for being able to price better than other people). If you start systematically putting orders in the market that you don't want to trade in order to influence other people's willingness to trade and then pulling the orders out then you can make money off those market makers. The problem is, that if you can trick people into doing bad trades they're going to be systematically losing money. This means they'll change their strategy - they can no longer trust the offers in the market as a source of information. So now, because they don't have reliable information on what other people in the market are offering, they can't be as confident, so they have to quote a wider spread between bid and ask. So now the average punter who wants to sell their position is going to pay a bigger premium to the market maker. So there's less liquidity and it's more expensive to use the market- which goes fundamentally against what the markets are there for.
- rolltiide 7y agoThe precursor settlement to the Ukrainian entity, Avalon's jury trial loss > Lek Securities will pay a $1 million penalty plus $525,892 in disgorgement and prejudgment interest, and Sam Lek will pay a $420,000 penalty. Curious what Avalon will do with the $25 million it earned. Sam Lek being an owner of Avalon as well.