28 ms·
There are a lot of people, especially on HN, that think delta_weight = calories_in - calories_burned is all there is to it. There is a lot of truth in that, bu
by phkahler 7y ago
There are a lot of people, especially on HN, that think delta_weight = calories_in - calories_burned is all there is to it. There is a lot of truth in that, but it seems to not be the whole story. Some eating habits cause us to eat more or less, while others seem to change our metabolism. What you eat and when you eat it seem to make a difference beyond just that simple equation.
- anthonypasq 7y ago> What you eat and when you eat it seem to make a difference beyond just that simple equation. evidence?
- Yeehaw789 7y agoGoogle epigenetics
- naasking 7y agoIt doesn't change the fundamental principles though. Meal timing and composition can affect how your body burns those calories (resting metabolic rate, thermic effect of food, etc.), but they're relatively minor effects overall. At best, meal composition and timing can improve adherence, and that's a very important factor.
- jjeaff 7y agoMinor effects that can have drastic effects over the long term. I have seen plenty of people wax about how metabolic variation in healthy people is only a few percentages. Well 2% is a HUGE difference. That means if two people eat exactly the same diet and same level of activity, assuming a 2000 calorie daily intake, the person with a 2% slower metabolism is going to be 40 lbs heavier over a 10 year period.
- naasking 7y agoMetabolic rate is not static. That 2% difference would not persist beyond a short time frame. Both bodies would down regulate metabolism to roughly the same levels given the same caloric deficit over time. One might change faster than the other, but the differences aren't as significant over longer time frames as you imply.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoA human body obeys thermodynamics.
- Yeehaw789 7y agoTrue. As well as when and what foods you eat may change your metabolism.
- rhinoceraptor 7y agoTo paraphrase Peter Attia, this is akin to answering the question, "Why is Bill Gates so rich?" with, "Because he gained more money than he spent". What we really care about is why people are eating more than they expend, and how we can get people to lose weight and maintain a healthy weight unconsciously.
- leshow 7y agoExcept in this case you can actually control how much money you get.
- gamblor956 7y agoFor the human body, chemistry matters more than thermodynamics... For example, diet soda has no calories, but has biochemical interactions that mimic those of regular soda, resulting in the trigger of hormones like insulin that trigger the body to store fat. Even worse, other biochemical reactions can kill the good gut flora lower down in your digestive system. Based on some studies, you're arguably better off just drinking regular soda despite the calories.
- Yeehaw789 7y agoHow is this downvoted? There is nothing even slightly controversial in that statement.
- logfromblammo 7y agoThat "delta_weight = calories_in - calories_burned" expression is absolutely technically correct--the best kind of correct. But... Some forget that calories_in is the output of a function with multiple input variables, and calories_burned is also the output of a function with multiple input variables, plus whatever your wrist-worn fitness monitor says you burned directly through exercise. If you stand in the freezing cold for 15 minutes, and then go back inside, and you still have some brown fat left after infancy, it will add to calories_burned for a little while. If you are insulin resistant, and you cut carbs out of your diet for a while, that will tend to deduct from calories_in, because the foods you are now eating impact your competing appetite and satiety functions differently, such that satiety is winning more often now. If you exercise vigorously, your calories_burned rises by when you burned directly, but you will also increase metabolism for a few hours afterward, and the fitness monitor won't tell you that, but it will also boost your appetite function, and your food scale might catch that.
- fredophile 7y agoIt really is just calories_in - calories_burned. If you change your eating habits and now eat less you have reduced calories_in. If you changed your eating habits and it boosted your metabolism you've increased calories_burned.
- jjeaff 7y agoCalories in minus calories burned minus calories passed through without metabolizing at all.
- snazz 7y agoHow significant is that unmetabolized calorie count in an average 2,000 calorie diet?
- gamblor956 7y agoDepends on your diet. For example, fiber is an un-digestible carb (to a human). If you eat a lot of veggies, wheat, or whole grains, you get a lot of fiber.
- fredophile 7y agoI used calories_burned because that's what the post I replied to used. calories_out would be more accurate and include undigested calories.
- phkahler 7y agoSure, but what if the increased metabolism has the same calorie intake as prior to the change? In that case "just eat less" is not what leads to weight loss, its "eat the right things". Ditto for the other changes that make one less hungry.
- fredophile 7y agoNeither my comment, nor your comment that I replied to, mentioned "just eat less". Your comment said that calories in minus calories out doesn't work. It does.
- homonculus1 7y ago>Some eating habits cause us to eat more or less, while others seem to change our metabolism. In other words, "calories in" and "calories burned".