4 ms·
I don't agree. It's not the whole population that will make the true revolution. They'll help, but are not the main stream of the revolution. Read my comment h
by csomar 16y ago
I don't agree. It's not the whole population that will make the true revolution. They'll help, but are not the main stream of the revolution.
Read my comment here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2151468 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2151468
Western Media has made false rumors that this is the Facebook revolution of young people. Yeah, Facebook played a major role, but wasn't the key.
There is torture in these countries. To break police torture, you MUST torture them. To torture them, you must have free people. People that don't have jobs, families, are not related to a school or university, have absolutely nothing that they can go to the streets and clash with the police.
There must be clashes with the police and blood. It's expensive to get your freedom. 30 Million protesters will not change Mubarak mind. He is a dictator. You need to get him out by force.
Will Egypt succeed? Too early to answer. The protests need to spread. I must mention that the protests in Tunisia spread to 100% of the country. Every meter square has protests of any kind. That thing drives police crazy and they give up.
Can Mubarak win? Absolutely. If the protests doesn't spread, a few thousands will be caught and tortured and the revolution will die. Fear will get back stronger to citizen. That's exactly what happened in Algeria.
- jacquesm 16y ago> To break police torture, you MUST torture them. I hope you meant that in a figurative sense and not in a literal one, if you meant that literally then I'm sorry, but that's absolutely not the case. You break a bad regime by doing better, not by becoming like them. I sincerely hope that El Baradei will get his way and will be allowed to lead a transition government he seems like a decent fellow and has done a lot of good by upholding a high standard of ethics at the IAEA (even when under considerable pressure to do otherwise) and I can not for one second imagine that he would condone torturing his former opponents. Some blood may flow but less is better, not worse. It's possible for a revolution to happen almost without bloodshed, typically mass strikes and walk-outs as opposed to violent clashes with representatives of the government. Gandhi: "Nonviolence is a weapon of the strong" edited: tx tsycho.
- sliverstorm 16y agoGandhi: "Nonviolence is a weapon of the strong" I sure don't blame the Egyptian people if they aren't feeling very strong right about now.
- tsycho 16y agoIt's Gandhi, not Ghandi. Sorry for nitpicking, but I hate to see the name mangled of someone I respect a lot.
- jacquesm 16y agoApologies, and it's not like I didn't know that, very sloppy of me. edited.
- tsycho 16y agoNo need to apologize since it was an honest mistake :) I have seen the wrong spelling used at many other places as well....not sure if they are always typos, or if some people are genuinely mistaken about the name.
- csomar 16y agoNo. I think you didn't understand. You may want to visit the Arabic countries. People here can't rise their voices. They risk getting fired, getting sued... Also you can't get all people to agree to go on strike. Get to the street, you'll find police waiting you. Fight, you don't have another choice. There is another point too: These strikes are led mainly by jobless people that have nothing in life. (Desperate people). So they are always in strike, they need to get their voice to the street. And if you have followed the Tunisian revolution, as it advances it gets more organised, that's because people began to gain power. And once they gain power, they consider that everything the state owns as their property too. In the past, they considered it as a property of the ancient regime.
- hellrich 16y agoPeaceful revolutions are possible, and I hope you will succeed with as little bloodshed as possible. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaceful_revolution_(German) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaceful_revolution_(German)
- presidentender 16y agoI do not agree that torture is the solution to torture. Resistance to imprisonment need not take the form of imprisonment, and there's little value in torture.