3 ms·
> Unlike carmakers, the airlines lack viable technological alternatives. Biofuels have potential but fully electric large commercial aircraft are probably decad
by einpoklum 7y ago
> Unlike carmakers, the airlines lack viable technological alternatives. Biofuels have potential but fully electric large commercial aircraft are probably decades away.
Huh? Sure they have alternatives: Fuel cells, or non-polluting combustible pairs of compounds, e.g. Hydrogen + Oxygen (or even Hydrogen + Air?) . Also, I'm no physicist, but I'm pretty sure it's more efficient to convert to kinetic energy (almost) directly rather than through electricity - meaning that electric engines don't make much sense.
Correct me if I'm wrong!
Also, even with current technology - passenger aircraft engine turbines are quite far from their maximum potential efficiency; see @baq's comment.
- leetcrew 7y agosmall nitpick, but hydrogen + oxygen combustion isn't really non-polluting unless you can do it in a vacuum. at high temperatures, the fuel also reacts with nitrogen in the atmosphere, creating NOx.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> Fuel cells These produce electricity, so I don't see how they are an alternative. > Hydrogen + Oxygen (or even Hydrogen + Air?) Hydrogen is highly reactive, and not likely a safe fuel for commercial air travel.
- dfgsgsgedag 7y ago"I'm pretty sure it's more efficient to convert to kinetic energy (almost) directly rather than through electricity - meaning that electric engines don't make much sense." An electric motor is >90% efficient. Sure you're added an extra stage converting to electricity, but so what? Electric drives are so efficient, diesel ICE locomotives have had electric drives (in lieu of transmissions) since the 1950s. That is, they have massive diesel engines that generate electricity instead of moving the train directly.
- Robotbeat 7y agoNo. Electric is the best way to convert renewable energy to useful flight energy. Anyway, it bothers me one people refer to the constraint being "large aircraft" when the real difficulty on electric flight is range, not how big the aircraft is. Electric flight scales up just fine. It's the range issue that's hardest. Currently can do 1000km, maybe up to 2000km with lithium ion and lithium sulfur chemistries with optimized structure and aerodynamics. Could scale up to larger sizes if desired.