3 ms·
> Is it also not true that GNOME, being open source, can at any time be forked (like MATE) and developed separately by those who disagree with where the project
by lmm 7y ago
> Is it also not true that GNOME, being open source, can at any time be forked (like MATE) and developed separately by those who disagree with where the project is going?
It's not true when they're unwilling to commit to stable interfaces (and indeed sometimes make changes that appear to break compatibility with forks for the sake of it). The reason GNU/Linux is based on Unix isn't that Unix was the best OS design, it's that Unix's loose coupling philosophy was the only thing that made rewriting it as open-source possible at all. If the only way to fork any one Linux program is to fork all of them (and that's the path we're going down) then you don't have freedom 3 in practice, even if the program is notionally under an open-source license.
> What do you suggest should happen instead? Wayland shouldn't happen?
If the cost of Wayland is removing the ability to be cross-platform then yes, it shouldn't happen. Microsoft manages to make their proprietary programs run on FreeBSD. NVidia manages to make their proprietary drivers run on FreeBSD. If a flagship open-source project can't manage to run cross-platform that's pathetic.