6 ms·
This is a lovely sentiment. I’m in awe of my own father’s capacity for work. He grew up in a village in Bangladesh and raised us in privilege in America. Russe
by rayiner 7y ago
This is a lovely sentiment. I’m in awe of my own father’s capacity for work. He grew up in a village in Bangladesh and raised us in privilege in America.
Russell I should add, was born into aristocracy, and was a romantic and communist sympathizer.
> Russell expressed great hope in "the Communist experiment." However, when he visited the Soviet Union and met Vladimir Lenin in 1920, he was unimpressed with the system in place. On his return he wrote a critical tract, The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism. He was "infinitely unhappy in this atmosphere—stifled by its utilitarianism, its indifference to love and beauty and the life of impulse." Although critical of its implementation in Soviet Russia, he still believed "that Communism is necessary to the world."
The world has tremendous labor to be done. Billions of people yearn to live the kind of comfortable life Russell lived. That won’t come to pass through idleness.
- lordlic 7y ago> The world has tremendous labor to be done. Is that so? There's already enough housing for everyone, with more empty houses than homeless people. Hunter-gatherer societies worked half or less as much as we do today, and they didn't have the benefit of industrialization. Production gets more and more efficient, but the workweek never gets shorter. Is this reasonable? > Billions of people yearn to live the kind of comfortable life Russell lived. That won’t come to pass through idleness. Idleness is the kind of comfortable life Russell lived. The alternative of working your fingers to the bone for your employer is a tragic waste of human potential.
- rayiner 7y ago> Idleness is the kind of comfortable life Russell lived. Russell was born into a wealthy British family. He grew up in the household of a former prime minister and inherited an earldom. He was able to enjoy idleness due to the labor of other British (not to mention the labor of Indians, Pakistanis, and Bangladeshis who enriched the British empire). Maybe one day we’ll invent replicators and be able to provide everyone—not only in Britain but in India/Bangladesh/Pakistan—with the comfort of Russell’s idle existence. Until then there is much labor to be done!
- lordlic 7y agoCompared with Russell's day, we have those magic replicators. Agricultural technology today is such that one farmer can feed thousands of people. We're off in an asymptote where we gets closer and closer to zero cost for basic needs, but the workweek never gets shorter. Clearly it would be ridiculous if one single farmer were able to support the needs of all of humanity but we still had to work the same as when each pre-industrial farmer only supported about 4 people. So at what point do we start seeing the benefits of this "replicator" (in the limit) technology?
- flukus 7y ago> So at what point do we start seeing the benefits of this "replicator" (in the limit) technology? When we stop consuming more and more. For the most part I could work a single day work week (at 1/5th of my comfy developer salary) and live a lifestyle better than Russell's, that easily covers all basic needs (including modern ones like internet access) with two exceptions. The first is the sin taxes (cigarettes and alcohol), these are avoidable but the latter is the sort of thing that makes life worthwhile. These are easy enough for society to eliminate if we want to decrease work hours. The second is housing costs, this is extremely complicated but suffice to say that we aren't at the optimum of what society can achieve, as evidenced by the fact that we've gone backwards in many ways. If you minimize pointless consumption, live modestly and as a society eliminate those two problems then an 8 hour work week seems achievable.
- rayiner 7y agoThis is pure fantasy. GDP per capita in the U.S. is $60,000 annually, with a 40-hour work week. Cut that to 8 hours, and we're looking at $12,000 per year. That's about the level of Tunisia. How much "pointless consumption" can we eliminate so that we can live what an American would consider a comfortable life within $12,000 per year? Does that include things like heroic medical care for end-of-live issues, nursing care for the elderly, etc?
- flukus 7y ago
- halleonard 7y agoGoogle "productivity vs labor graph". In the US at least, the "tremendous labor to be done" is a lie that keeps grows each and every year.
- fallous 7y agoExcept that the parent specifically stated "the world" and not "the US."
- sedeki 7y agoWow - what happened in 1974? Something that has to do with the gold standard?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThe oil crisis? Followed by Thatcher and Reagan? Arrival of the shipping container?
- sedeki 7y agoNixon famously took the US, and thus the world, off the gold standard in 1971, effectively giving the Fed a carte blanche to print money. To me this alone would explain the flatness. I sense some sarcasm in your comment - maybe it doesn’t to you.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI sense some sarcasm in your comment That wasn't my intention.
- phaemon 7y agoOh, right, you think you know the answer already. Coincidentally, in the collection of essays "In Praise of Idleness" the fourth one is called, "The Modern Midas", written in 1932. You might enjoy it.
- 7y ago