5 ms·
Google Capone: "Hey, nytimes.com, your site loads awful slow. We're gonna have to put this badge of shame on it for everyone to see. Now, if you just dumped y
by reaperducer 7y ago
Google Capone: "Hey, nytimes.com, your site loads awful slow. We're gonna have to put this badge of shame on it for everyone to see.
Now, if you just dumped your other ad networks and ran everything through us, I bet it would be load much faster and that badge might magically disappear..."
- sneak 7y agoI think you misspelled AMP.
- flukus 7y ago> Now, if you just dumped your other ad networks and ran everything through us, I bet it would be load much faster and that badge might magically disappear... My experience with everything google has touched lately suggest that this wouldn't improve speed any. Gmail and youtube make continental drift look speedy and even the search page takes 1.4MB and takes over a second to load for me (maybe corporate network issue), that's approaching the size of doom to display a dozen links. Google doesn't have any moral authority when it comes to bloat. Edit - for reference HN takes about the same time to load, but that has to cross the pacific ocean whereas google supposedly has local data centers.
- alttag 7y agoThere's a big difference between "done loading" and "appears to be done loading". Google is reportedly very cautious about the latter, and pulls some hijinks to appear faster than it is. Frankly, I'd be happier if more sites paid a similar level of attention. That said, if your search page takes over a second, you're right, it might be an issue with your network.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoI think the point being made is that it's no longer actually about the speed, it's about the 'badge of shame'. The analogy being used is accurate, in that 'protection money' isn't, and was never, about protection.
- Avamander 7y agoThe only PC where I saw Gmail being fast was a Ryzen 9 3900x build, I suspect that if Google devs were given shittier PCs they'd build faster products that would appeal more to the average user.
- cameronh90 7y agoI run a Core i5-2500K from 2011 and Gmail runs just fine. Far better than Thunderbird or Outlook ever did, but it does take a lot of memory.
- zbrozek 7y agoI have a Google-issued corporate workstation with 64 GB of RAM and 12 cores. Gmail is really really slow. Like so slow that I if I have to refresh it I'll go get coffee. But I'm on Firefox, and so "I Am Not The User" and all that.
- cameronbrown 7y agoIMO the best way to use Gmail is to open and pin it, only load once a day. It seems optimised for this use case.
- shscs911 7y agoEven better, just run Gmail in basic HTML mode. This way you can even open emails in their own tabs. Sure, you lose a bit of functionality, but its well worth the tradeoff, in my opinion.
- jfoster 7y agoPart of the problem is that they place high importance on the first contentful paint (aka FCP) above all else. They're not very much looking at how it performs overall, mostly just how long it takes for a user to see the first bit of content. If that were a bit of text that said "loading" with a spinner that goes for a minute or two, they may consider that fast.
- kaycebasques 7y agoThis section shows how Lighthouse calculates your overall Performance score: https://web.dev/performance-scoring/#lighthouse-6 https://web.dev/performance-scoring/#lighthouse-6 (Note that the table gets cut off on narrow mobile screens... I’ll file a bug) FCP is 20% of the score. The other metrics capture different milestones in the loading experience. For example Total Blocking Time is intended to bring awareness to sites that may look complete but can’t respond to user input (because the main thread is busy running JS). The metrics overview that we just launched provides more detail about how our metrics were designed to capture the end-to-end loading experience (or at least that’s what we’re working towards): https://web.dev/user-centric-performance-metrics/ https://web.dev/user-centric-performance-metrics/ So in the case of your site-that-just-loads-a-spinner example, yes it might have a good FCP time, but it’s LCP time probably wouldn’t be that good, and therefore the overall Performance score would be mediocre. Long story short, I don’t think it’s as easy to game a good Performance score as you might think Disclosure: I work on web.dev
- jefftk 7y ago> that has to cross the pacific ocean whereas google supposedly has local data centers HN is behind Cloudflare, and so also has local DCs
- microcolonel 7y agoThey would be.... an extremely unwise website to target with that kind of extortion.
- andrewstuart2 7y agoOh, definitely don't start with NYT. Come back to them once there's little other choice.
- buboard 7y agotheir site is pure hidden text spam (aka paywall) and they still give them views. i don't know why you'd say that
- jfoster 7y agoActually one of the things that Lighthouse (Chrome's speed test tool) complains about a lot is some of the things that are a result of using Google's AdSense.
- joegahona 7y agoIt also throws penalties for using Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics.
- beaner 7y agoKind of a good sign that Google's internal teams actually work independently and don't give special exemptions to other units of the company?
- Semaphor 7y agoWay back, the chrome website got penalized by Google (the search engine) for disallowed SEO tricks ;)
- darkwater 7y agoThat's how it works now, but they can fix it internally whenever they feel like to...
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoI actually seriously have my doubts about that.
- joegahona 7y agoThe way that the Google Search unit gives preference to Google AMP unit in its mobile results? Yes, I suppose it's a good sign that they don't also give that sort of exemption here, but I would consider that expected, not praiseworthy.
- kaycebasques 7y agoWe’ve also got a section on web.dev focusing on the specific problems that 3rd-party resources can create and how to fix them: https://web.dev/fast/#optimize-your-third-party-resources https://web.dev/fast/#optimize-your-third-party-resources We mention that ad scripts are a common type of problematic 3rd-party resource but we use the phrase “3rd-party resource” because there are lots of other common problematic scripts, like A/B tests, social media widgets, and analytics scripts. Disclosure: I work on web.dev
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]