> Without the US government playing it's current role, I am 100% confident that the US health data that is currently confidential would stop being confidential.

> Without the US government playing it's current role, I am 100% confident that the US health data that is currently confidential would stop being confidential. The fact that the government has passed a law that requires private entities to keep PHI confidential says nothing about their competence in managing PHI of their own. The original claim is about the latter.