3 ms·
I'm not Keynesian. I think the past few years have disproved it. Actually I think the past few decades have disproved it and I can't help but be a bit cynical a
by jerf 16y ago
I'm not Keynesian. I think the past few years have disproved it. Actually I think the past few decades have disproved it and I can't help but be a bit cynical about how a superceded (for good and sufficient reasons) economic theory suddenly revived itself when the government needed it. Destroying wealth occurs when you pay money to sit on their hands. Currency is moving around, but it's not doing anything, and given that wealth is actually consumed to keep people alive (they eat, they live somewhere, etc), if they aren't generating enough wealth to even offset that consumption (let alone a surplus) then there's wealth destruction going on.
Look at the situation in isolation for a moment. Dollars go in to the unemployed house, a roughly equal number of dollars flow out, that all looks neutral. But that's just currency. Look at the flow of wealth. Food flows in and disappears. Housing is consumed. Wear and tear is put on possessions. Imagine if absolutely everybody in the economy is doing that, not because this is actually possible but because it shows the situation in stark colors. It doesn't matter how many dollars you pump into that economy, it can't work, the food and shelter and objects for possessions have to come from somewhere. That's the difference between "currency" and "wealth" in a nutshell. You can't fix the economy by shuffling money around and shutting down wealth production. (Nor is the government all that good at wealth production. How much mining does the government do? How much food does it grow? It's more complicated than that, but this is closer than most other ways of thinking about it.) So...
'If I consult my phrasebook, "destroying wealth" is usually code for "taxing the wealthy."'
No, not even close, when I say it. I actually mean real wealth is being consumed and not replaced, nothing to do with taxes. That's what actually matters, not little dollar symbols. An excessive obsession with the dollars while ignoring the wealth is arguably the main reason the government's response has been so inadequate. Taking money away from people generating wealth and shunting it into a wide variety of ineffective areas of the economy makes things worse, not better.
There's no way out of this entire problem, of which over-extended benefits is only one small part, without pain. You think you have a solution to easing the pain, and it does ease it locally, but your way generates more pain globally, and eventually that catches up to us. Like, the last couple of years and the ways things are going the next few years too. Again, I reject your attempt at moral authority. Your way leads to disaster, the one we're all but headed full bore for right now. That pain is necessary now is not because of my choices today, it is because of the choices already made. I'm not advocating pain, I'm announcing the fact it's already here. We've got a gangrenous limb and you're upset because I'm not willing to go along with the "keep pumping more anesthetic in and it's all fine because there's no pain" plan. Yeah, I'm not, but I don't think I'm the one with a morality problem when I suggest the gangrenous limb should be addressed sooner rather than later.