6 ms·
The moral panic around deepfakes is hilarious to me. Especially on a platform like Twitter where a tweet of a screenshot of a headline with no source (that pos
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
The moral panic around deepfakes is hilarious to me.
Especially on a platform like Twitter where a tweet of a screenshot of a headline with no source (that possible has no source) will have thousands of upvotes and angry responses which is much more alarming and something that already exists today.
For example, every once in a while on r/PoliticalHumor you'll see a screenshot of a tweet that Trump didn't even write, yet everyone responding will take it at face value. Deepfakes are a red herring and a distraction from a ubiquitous phenomenon we might never solve.
Requiring deepfakes to have a disclaimer to me is like training people that it's safe to insert their credit card info on a website as long as they see the https lock icon in the navbar. Instead, people should be trained to be eternally vigilant and to be skeptical even if there is no "this is fake" disclaimer.
We're long past screwed.
- hart_russell 7y agoAgreed. In general, it feels like modern America lacks critical thinking skills when it comes to discerning obviously fake information from real.
- account73466 7y agonothing to do with America, it is worldwide and thousands years long.
- mcshay79 7y agoBeing a modern American who lacks important critical thinking skills, I would like to ask you how it is that I am to discern obviously fake information from real information? Or perhaps a better question: what is true?
- behringer 7y agoTo be fair, as a general rule, I assume all Trump quotes are real until proven otherwise.
- m-p-3 7y agoI only trust a tweet legitimacy if it's a link to the original tweet, or if it's an archive of the original tweet. Anything else can be faked.
- behringer 7y agoYeah but Trump says the stupidest garbage all the time. I don't have time to fact check if every word he says really came out of his mouth. I'll just presume it's true until pointed out in the comments.
- ShorsHammer 7y agoYou're right on the money here. It's a distraction from the underlying issue. Instilling critical thinking in the population might not be desirable from a politicians perspective but it's reached the point of being a national security issue. Plenty of handy tools for the aspiring fake tweeter too: https://www.tweetgen.com/create/tweet.html https://www.tweetgen.com/create/tweet.html
- mc32 7y agoThe problem goes further than that. Obviously there are agreed upon facts, but so many things are arguable. So many things suffer from propaganda (our diets) to indoctrination in schools (lots of things, both left and right, but now mostly left). Very few people read up on history and follow a garden path to education and realization. It’s very few people. Most people heed a “trusted source” like their club, their union, their mentors, their teachers, etc.
- cheald 7y agoVery well said. We outsource our critical thinking at our own peril. People are very good at believing what they want to, and the more we encourage them to turn off their skepticism because something has a little badge on it, the worse off we all are.
- slowmovintarget 7y agoIt almost seems like Twitter has a decided it has a vested interest in attempting to become an arbiter of veracity. That does seem a dangerous crutch to rely on.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoIsn't that why it is even more important that deepfakes aren't on there?