3 ms·
War, as in pitched battles on a field, has been going away for a long time. Perpetual war, unfortunately, is back. If you believe Clauzewitz's dictum that "wa
by gumby 7y ago
War, as in pitched battles on a field, has been going away for a long time. Perpetual war, unfortunately, is back.
If you believe Clauzewitz's dictum that "war is diplomacy by any other means" then than disinformation, continual, slow, background degradation of the infrastructure of perceived enemies and the like will become the standard mode of large nation states, with actual shooting being the guerrilla/terrorist activity of those who can't afford the electronic ops. Something that also has been the nature of the world since forever (David/Goliath, US revolution, WWII partisans, Al Qaida....any so many in between).
And BTW once you have this capability wouldn't you use it internally to "ensure domestic tranquility"?
Once again The Sheep Look Up and Stand on Zanzibar are highly predictive.
- emilfihlman 7y agoWar is a special case of competition, ie competition through violence, violent competition of nations or large body actors. But calling perpetual competition war because is questionable. We have always been influencing each other. It's not war.
- gumby 7y agoI specifically don't mean perpetual "competition" so thanks for flagging that I was not clear. I consider competition to be not just commercial competition, colonial (ugh) competition, spying and the like. Spying in fact can avert war (well understood in game theory, hence the overflight treaties). But when spend time specifically probing and actually attacking, say, your perceived opponents' infrastructure (e.g. "cyberattack" of another country's electronic grid) I consider that warfare. Student was unambiguously an act of war, though Iran was too weak to respond (also: clever!). In particular Iran posed no threat to the US, but attacking its nuclear capabilities served US geopolitical interests (Iran did and does threaten US allies). If you destroy or degrade someone's capabilities remotely instead of sending a high explosive, do you not consider that perpetual war? Developing such capabilities is not, inherently, war, nor is probing for weaknesses. But if the US considers Russia an adversary (a small economy, large land and population next to various allies) I can see how someone could consider it reasonable to make it harder for its government to function. I disagree, and do consider it warfare.