3 ms·
> just go the amateur route? But how do you even go the amateur route? You still won't be able to distribute what you make. A big part of my childhood was mak
by cortesoft 7y ago
> just go the amateur route?
But how do you even go the amateur route? You still won't be able to distribute what you make.
A big part of my childhood was making games, and sharing them on shareware sites in the mid 90s. It sucks that kids today aren't going to be able to do that. There was no way I could afford $100 as a 10 year old.
- PeterisP 7y agoThing is, for the common scenario of "safe enough for random users to install" we want some barrier of entry. The market where random creations of a ten year old are acceptable isn't the Apple Store, it's something like Roblox environment for user-created content or some other sandbox that is (a) isolated from the rest of the system and (b) makes it clear that it's likely not to meet even the (already low) standards of the generic Store. For all the major means of distribution the problem isn't not enough apps, the problem is too much garbage - so the direction of improving end-user experience is more filtering of apps and developers, not easier access to distribution.
- Razengan 7y agoThat is exactly what some developers just can't seem to get: Many users agree with Apple. But those developers are going: "No those users are wrong and should join my mob to make Apple let me do whatever I want to users' systems."
- birdyrooster 7y agoThe amateurs will have to start distributing source. I remember back in the day when I was a kid making GameMaker games on Mac in the late 90s, sometimes I would collaborate with other developers and we would just send the source files around which were completely useable, but of course we wanted to distribute executables as if we were legitimate companies, even though our users were typically other kid developers. We had fake company names and stuff, but if we were emulating open source projects instead of cloistered corporations, we could've gotten more done together. I predict this change will cause kids to embrace open source more and distribute their projects in a way that can be shared and reused.
- indigochill 7y agoI hypothesize "fantasy consoles"* are potentially fertile ground for young developers. They impose a lot of restrictions, but to someone starting out that means fairly low limits to understanding the basics of the environment (as opposed to something like UE4). They're also cheap or free. And some of them (like PICO-8) host user-created games. *https://github.com/paladin-t/fantasy https://github.com/paladin-t/fantasy
- unlinked_dll 7y agoWell you could write your game in JS and deliver it over the web. Flash games were all the rage when I was a kid. But for now, non-notarized executables don't fail, they just need to be enabled by an admin account through permissions.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoConsider though that flash was a security dumpster fire that coincidentally ran as fast as something unburdened by security concern, and that the most certainly pirated full Adobe suite used by a young beginner developer was installed by some sketchy exe that would no way be notarized by any sort of authority
- gfodor 7y agoYou surely can’t be oblivious to how this has been a process of boiling the frog slowly — almost certainly they will eventually be permanent-blocked like on iOS.
- coldtea 7y agoYou surely can't be oblivous that, user wise (security, ease of use) this is a process of improvement slowly... MacOS might have bugs due to neglect, bad priorties, too fast deprecations, etc. But all the extra restrictions (notarization, sandboxing, dropping 32-bits, etc) are in the right direction for a consumer platform (i.e. not for devs), for making the computers easier and more secure, like appliances that just do what you bought them for. And they will be part of any/all platforms going forward (including Windows, and new platforms like Fucscia). As for Linux, it exists for 2.5 decades, it has been free since forever, it's still not adopted by the masses. It's not in the direction that most want.
- gfodor 7y agoI'm not sure who you're arguing with, but the poster I was replying to noted the status quo is that you can run unnotarized executables. To your point, that should not be taken to mean that we won't eventually see it evaporate. On the contrary, we should assume it will.
- bilbo0s 7y agoYou can still do that, you just have to find users dumb enough to authorize the running of an application downloaded randomly from the internet. Oh, and they need to authorize it from an admin account. So, yeah. Not sure there are a lot of people out there that dumb. Unless you're some well known downloaded product like Blender or something, I would think you would have a hard time getting people to run your software. At the same time, to be completely fair, you probably should have a hard time getting people to run your software. That's pretty much exactly how a lot of malware is distributed.