3 ms·
I think TDP is becoming less and less of a comparable figure. All designs could use far more power in specific worst case corner cases (eg. a very specific ins
by londons_explore 7y ago
I think TDP is becoming less and less of a comparable figure. All designs could use far more power in specific worst case corner cases (eg. a very specific instruction stream that causes every functional unit to be in use every cycle, and all data paths to toggle logic state every cycle).
Yet in the typical use case (desktop PC, most cores idle most of the time), power consumption will be far lower.
What really matters is the graph of "how much computation can I get out of this thing in 10ms bursts, 1 second bursts, and 10 minute bursts?", with a specific cooling setup.
- x3ro 7y agoI'm not sure whether people use $2k CPUs in "most of the time all cores are idle" scenarios a lot.
- concerned_user 7y agoEven if they don't, 10-15% performance gain for double the price seems questionable. If you include the specialized motherboard, chillers, high speed ram even more so. Maybe in some very specific scenarios it would work like some VR prototype or flight sim, but for majority of users it doesn't make economic sense.
- pizza234 7y agoIt's correct that TDP is getting more relative¹, but it's not correct that we're talking of corner cases. Anandtech locked an i9-9900k to 95W, and the loss was considerable (between 8 and 28%)². ¹: it needs to be noted that in the last years, Intel's TDP is getting "much more relative" than AMD's ²: https://www.anandtech.com/show/13591/the-intel-core-i9-9900k-at-95w-fixing-the-power-for-sff/9 https://www.anandtech.com/show/13591/the-intel-core-i9-9900k...
- pingyong 7y agoIntel TDP always had the same meaning: "If your cooler can dissipate TDP, the CPU will run all-core loads at base clock speed, or a single-core loads at boost-clock speed." - Pretty sure that statement has always been true, within +- 100 MHz depending on the specific workload. The distance between base and boost clocks has just increased over the years.
- mike_hock 7y agoConsidering Intel has already ditched barely-meaningful TDP for completely meaningless SDP (the "dynamic contrast" of processor wattage), I'd say it already isn't a comparable figure.