5 ms·
In many urban and suburban parts of the USA there's specific ordinances against manufactured housing, because of shoddily built singlewide and doublewide "mobil
by walrus01 7y ago
In many urban and suburban parts of the USA there's specific ordinances against manufactured housing, because of shoddily built singlewide and doublewide "mobile homes" that people who already own property in the area don't want put in place, for fear of driving down property values.
Unfortunately this also tends to encompass the definition of many higher end manufactured homes, or even prefab/modular housing that might cost more than a stick built 1600 sq ft bungalow.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoExcuse the stereotypes in this observation but it's kinda funny that (some) Americans firmly believe that they have the right to own whatever guns they wish, that if my neighbor doesn't have health insurance that's his problem but woe betide him if he dares live in an ugly home.
- WalterBright 7y agoBeing in an ugly home affects the property values of the neighbors. Having guns or health insurance does not.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoCounter-point: living in an ugly home isn't going to kill anyone.
- homonculus1 7y agoThere are more civilian-owned guns than people in the US. The exact number isn't known but let's ballpark it very conservatively at 400,000,000. There are about 13,000 homicides by firearm each year, including justified ones but let's also conservatively ignore those. Now to be extremely conservative let's make the ridiculous assumption that those homicides are evenly distributed throughout gun-owning population, and not correlated to any particular individuals, demographics, or social circumstances. So then having assumed guns are the problem in the first place, and not say, violent urban gangs, your neighbors' still only have at most a 0.00325% annual chance of being used to kill someone. I don't know what your threshold is but to me that's firmly in "not going to kill anyone" territory. A trailer next door being ugly, though, is guaranteed!
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI wasn't trying to start a gun control debate. I just found the contrast between the defense of personal rights and restricting the rights of others interesting in this case.
- homonculus1 7y agoYou're right, in general a lot of people pay lip service to higher principles when it's convenient, but as soon as the issue is something they don't like then there are all kinds of vague second-order reasons why the mere potential of another person's rights are harmful and must be restricted. Zoning laws and gun regulation are both great examples. But as another commenter pointed out I suspect that there's actually more overlap between these particular issues than otherwise, they're both hallmarks of well-off suburbanites who want protection from the rabble.
- zwkrt 7y agoSo living in an ugly home is the only one of the three with no effect on the physical well-being of others?
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoI think you're mixing and matching political sub groups to find a contradiction that mostly doesn't exist. One of the places that gun control is popular is affluent suburbs. This is also where regressive zoning is popular. The major exception I can think of is the Southeast where gun control really isn't very popular at all outside the inner city but many affluent neighborhoods are HOA'd to hell and back. I assure you, the hardcore libertarian "my tactical nukes are none of the government's business" types have no love for zoning.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoYeah, I think that's a good point. While the contradiction may exist when taking the country as a whole; there are few individuals for who that contradiction actually applies.
- pfdietz 7y agoIt's intended to exclude low cost housing, with the intent of excluding the poor, especially racial minorities. "Shoddiness" is just an excuse. See also: zoning.
- CalRobert 7y agoFor what it's worth, the nicest house I ever lived in was a modular home on a hillside in San Luis Obispo. Zillow has it over $600k atm. In other places, there can be discrimination and prejudice - mobile homes are a favoured accommodation of Irish Travelers and it's illegal to use a mobile home for non-temporary accommodation in Ireland.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoAn interesting twist on this is in rural areas or the exurban fringe, it's common to see large multimillion dollar estates next to decaying mobile homes and middle class 3+2 ranch style homes. There seems to be very little friction between the different housing types.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoThis is actually the situation I'm living in. I live out in the country and while my house isn't a mobile home, it is more than 3x smaller than my neighbor's gigantic palace across the street.