5 ms·
"the argument is that British police are not as afraid, so don't engage in excessive force as often, because there aren't guns around that could be used to kill
by pmoriarty 7y ago
"the argument is that British police are not as afraid, so don't engage in excessive force as often, because there aren't guns around that could be used to kill them"
From what I've read, this has been changing in recent years, with British police getting more and more armed, apparently in response to terrorists and organized crime being better armed.
So the US and British police are converging, but perhaps not in the way that gun control advocates might have hoped.
- alasdair_ 7y agoA regular officer in the UK still doesn’t carry a firearm. There ARE plenty of Firearms Officers around but they receive significantly more training than a typical US officer and are usually only there to respond to armed crime, or at major airports etc.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThe Police Federation, the association for low and medium rank police, regularly sounds out officers' view of their being armed. The public is keener on armed police than the police are - thanks to idiot perspectives from the likes of the Daily Mail. Police themselves are always overwhelmingly against - like usually 80 or 90% against when polled. They get tasers - though even those don't seem universal - even that was considered a step too far by many. Firearms officers will remain - thankfully - volunteers subject to significant extra training, psychological screening and oversight. When mistakes or negligence happen they make front page news. There are more firearms units and more in visible positions like airports and other protection than there used to be, but they remain a small minority of the overall.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoWhen mistakes or negligence happen, they make front page news in the United States, too.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoOK, then I should have expressed it better - it's vanishingly rare. Even armed officers are expected to de-escalate when possible, rather than shoot. There's been some questionable sounding incidents amongst the very low numbers of actual shootings, and of course there are sometimes major cock-ups - a couple of which that sounded seriously negligent. Wikipedia says in the year 2011–12, conventional firearms were used FIVE times. At the time there were 6,756 Authorised Firearms Officers and 12,550 police operations in which firearms were authorised throughout England and Wales. Which doesn't sound like UK:US convergence to me. :)
- solidsnack9000 7y agoI agree with your point to the effect that US and UK are not converging in this area. What are differences in UK training? I imagine the training is very good because the confidence not to over-react in self-defense comes from knowing (a) that you can handle many situations and (b) how to assess the situation you when are in it.
- HatchedLake721 7y agoThey are not converging, not even close, please don’t spread misinformation. In 12 months up to March 2018, there were 18,746 armed police operations in the UK. Weapons were fired on 12 occasions. In comparison, 1,147 people were shot dead by police in the US in 2017. Since 1990, a total of 70 people were fatally shot in the UK. 12 occasions of guns used vs 1,147 people shot by the police during the same time frame. 70 people killed in 30 years vs 1,147 in 1 year. So please, UK and US police are not converging, do not spread misinformation.
- adrianN 7y agoFor correctness sake you should normalize your numbers for population, but your point of course still stands.
- logicchains 7y agoUsing raw numbers without adjusting for population is spreading misinformation. America's population is ~5x greater. Using numbers from 1990 is also meaningless for addressing the claim that gun use by UK police is increasing, as low numbers could just represent it being low in past.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoSo if all gun deaths in the UK since 1990 were also in the last month then the 2 systems are converging?
- in_cahoots 7y agoJust looking at the 2017 numbers, a 5x population difference cannot account for a nearly 100x difference between uses of armed force vs people being killed by the police.