5 ms·
I think what's being missed in the discussion on HN is the reason CPL eliminated fines. It's not about the money, nor is it about getting the books back. It's
by reaperducer 7y ago
I think what's being missed in the discussion on HN is the reason CPL eliminated fines. It's not about the money, nor is it about getting the books back. It's to improve access to the library system.
CPL did a study of who held the cards with suspended privileges because of late fees, and found out that the vast majority were people in poor neighborhoods, and of those the vast majority were children.
Now with the new rules it opens up book borrowing again to tens of thousands of people who need it most.
/CPL cardholder.
- jcims 7y agoInteresting. I noted below that the libraries could work with the post office to get books back efficiently, but based on this they should probably start with school libraries instead.
- consp 7y agoThe "library" in my school (sub 13 years old, the library was a few bookcases at best for a school of ~120 kids) had books from the central library in the town. You could look up a book, reserve it and it would be delivered next week if available (no internet then, so it was a computer with the book list and reservation cards you had to fill in). If it was not available you would get a notice when it would arrive. Or you took your bike and drove the 5km but as a small kid that is not always an option and you'd have to get your parents to bring or help you get there. You could return all books there even if you picked them up elsewhere in the same library system. It's sort of a postal system I guess. It didn't get used too often, but it was a nice addition to the rotating book supply that was otherwise available. And it was also a nice learning experience for us small kids about how the libraries worked and we got to use computers.
- 60654 7y agoThis seems like an excellent move on the part of the library system and mayor's office. I don't have a horse in this race (no late books in a long time) but it's great to see this being implemented for everybody's benefit.
- mumblemumble 7y agoEven if you return all your books on time, it's still valuable, because of the huge jump they're seeing in the rate at which books are returned. Random anecdote: About 15 years ago, I was looking for a somewhat obscure book, and found that it was something like 6 months overdue. Later on, while hanging out with a friend, I mentioned this to a friend who had a common interest in the subject matter, with some comment to the effect of, "What happened there!?" Well, this friend went over to his bookshelf, picked a book off the shelf, and handed it to me. It was the very same 6 month overdue book I had been looking for. He explained that he had lost it somewhere, and, by the time he had found it, the fines were already up to something like $50, which he couldn't afford, and he wasn't done reading it yet, so he figured he might as well keep it since it was the last library book he'd ever be checking out. IIRC the statistic quoted when CPL announced this program suggests that some version of that story was playing out for thousands and thousands of books every year. Which negatively affects access to information for everyone in the city, not just the people who were getting slapped with fines.
- kunai 7y agoWonder how rayiner is going to pop up in this thread to tell us how this is a terrible thing.
- eecc 7y agoAlso the Amsterdam Public Library does the same, just for junior cards though. I guess it’s a common scenario
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThe Santa Cruz (California) City/County Public Library System didn't apply late fees to junior cards as of 15-20 years ago. In all likelihood they still don't.
- vanniv 7y agoSo, I'm curious. Did they require that the books be returned in order to open up borrowing again? Like, just, "please bring the books back, we'll disappear the fees and just take 'em back and all is forgiven"? Or did they just... reactivate the accounts and hope that history won't repeat? (Genuinely curious -- the articles I've read on the subject, like this one, are all excited about more library everything, but quite light on real info)
- reaperducer 7y agoMy understanding is they just wiped the slate clean. Returning the missing material was not required. But that's based on a radio report I don't remember well, so I could be wrong.
- jmahyoung 7y agoYour proposal seems reasonable and a fair way to prevent a few bad actor patrons from stealing the whole library and then claiming no repercussions.
- mumblemumble 7y agoIf you lose the book, you can replace it with another copy in good condition. The policy used to be that you had to pay whatever the library paid for it, which could be quite a penny if they bought one of the library editions. Now a $7 trade paperback will do.
- vkizl 7y agoBeing poor prevents you from returning books in time.
- tux1968 7y agoBeing young means you're less likely to be totally responsible yet. Being poor means you're less likely to have parents that are 100% engaged in your library visits.
- smileysteve 7y agoSmall fines seem like a great way to instill a sense of responsibility (while also acting as insurance style payments), especially if your parents already aren't engaged and ensuring you're responsible to duties. As this the Good Will Hunting quote suggests, in many libraries these fees were small, $1.25 in late fees for a Harvard Education...
- moate 7y agoSure, they seem like that. But the study Chicago conducted showed that fines increased patron anxiety and were antithetical to the intended goals of library leadership in engaging their patrons. So it actually may have actually been detrimental.
- eevilspock 7y agoBeing rich enables you to return books as late as you want because the fine means little to you, and certainly not whether you can eat or pay the rent.
- eevilspock 7y agothank you. this brought a tear to my eye. it is the antithesis of the social darwinism that coldly dominates our culture.
- aquadrop 7y agoOh yeah, that once was a big problem for me when I was something like 9 years old. I was using library a lot and one day I lost the book. And there were fines for that and for late return as well. I didn't tell my parents because we didn't have a lot of money, so that would be a problem. I saved my lunch money etc for two months and then went to the library to solve the problem. They were pretty nice about it and let me to replace the book with cheap another one, which I bought right outside the library, so even didn't spend all the money I saved. Seems funny now, but it was a major source of anxiety for me back then :)
- saalweachter 7y agoAll problems are big when you are little.
- beokop 7y agoAll problems are small with perspective!