8 ms·
Key details of Galileo satellite summer failure emerge
- ginko 7y agoThe title makes it sound like galileo went down again. Can someone please change it?
- bigiain 7y agoSince the whole original headline is too long, I'd suggest "The tale of Europe’s Galileo satellites going dark"
- dredmorbius 7y agoEmailing hn@ycombinator.com frequently produces a fairly quick remedy. I've suggested borrowing from the lede: "Key details about the failure of Europe’s Galileo satellite system over the summer have started to emerge - and it’s not pretty." "Key details of Galileo satellite summer failure emerge" should work, at 55 characters (limit is 80). That's the suggestion I'd submitted.
- dang 7y agoWe'll take it. Thanks!
- woliveirajr 7y agoI'm not sure how a system with complex and tight requirements is able to run with so many organizations taking care of pieces...
- bigiain 7y agoPurely by luck. As the report the article is writing about outlines... https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/state-of-galileo-and-accident/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/state-of-galileo-and-accid...
- smitty1e 7y agoWhat is luck? Typically a technically competent underground develops that can tunnel through the organizational morass imposed by the homo bureaucratus infestation expressed in the org chart, and somehow accomplish the mission.
- outside1234 7y agoIt doesn’t run, you aren’t missing anything. :)
- outside1234 7y agoShould be titled: “Project being run in part by Thales so of course it failed”
- londons_explore 7y agoA few defence companies have noticed that failed projects tend to lead to them getting given more money to fix the problem. They now deliberately make their projects useless (but still technically meeting the contractual requirements) simply so they get the followup contract to make things better. One project I worked on had 10 times we had deliberately gimped the system and the client had come and paid us more money to ungimp it. (For example, we designed an email client, but "@dhs.gov" was hardcoded in the address field so you couldn't send an email to anywhere else from the system. Then it cost millions of taxpayer money to un-hardcode that, despite it being a 1 line code change)
- toyg 7y agoThat’s a bit too precise for comfort, if I were you I’d anonymize it a bit more. Civil liability for fraud is a thing.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoThis sounds too blatant to be true, but even so I imagine it's the decision-maker that would be responsible.
- londons_explore 7y agoI changed the hardcoded domain in my example... Either way, it was no secret that or system could only send emails to a specific domain - both we and the customer knew that. And they paid us $XM to give it the ability to send emails to anywhere.
- illys 7y agoAbout software, it is not typical to defense companies and it does not need to be deliberate: most consultancy and subcontracting companies have no incentive to exceed a crappy average level: Indeed, as you explain, being fast and excellent makes you poorer when you have a day rate and when your next contract depends on the maintenance of the software you create (since you are the only expert).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jdsnape 7y agoThis is really a re-write of Bert's great piece on the outage, which was discussed a couple of days ago - if you're interested, I strongly recommend you go read it https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21476451 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21476451
- throw0101a 7y agoThe article mentions Bert and links to his post. El Reg is an IT(-ish) site, and so tries to summarize things for the general tech-y public that may be of interest.
- goatinaboat 7y agoIn fact Bert himself is answering questions in the comments.
- biscotte_ 7y agoMost of the things managed by the EU end up this way. When you are trying to manage a project with 28different votes and political powers, all pulling in a different direction, this happens.
- CraigJPerry 7y agoIs there a better alternative than democracy? Perhaps no cooperation, every country for itself. That seems like a sure fire way to constantly lose to bigger blocs of countries at every turn. Single ruler is another obvious but seems like an unfavourable outcome.
- toyg 7y agoYeah, people tend to forget that any equivalent superpower is dramatically more undemocratic than the EU. Electoral college and presidential prerogatives, anyone?
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoIt's not so much democracy, but the lack of a rational governmental framework that's the problem. The EU is what you get when you try to integrate a couple dozen countries, but end up making a bunch of dirty compromises and band-aid solutions, and when nobody even agrees on what the end goal of is (The United States of Europe? A loose confederation of independent states?). It's not what you'd get if you were to design a reasonable federal constitution from scratch.
- close04 7y ago> dirty compromises and band-aid solutions Were the US or UK any different at the start? Founded by conquest and agreements, they involved a lot of give and take on all sides. Even ~100 years after independence and signing the Constitution the US was in the middle of a civil war with the compromises that followed. The only way to have a union that doesn't require compromises is if everyone is on the exact same page. And that simply can't happen the second you cross a border (most times even inside that border). Once the union is created you start trying to homogenize and give it time.
- sulekhaholidays 7y agoThe only way to have a union that doesn't require compromises is if everyone is on the exact same page Sulekha Tour Package - Planning Tour? Book Tour Package online from Sulekha Holidays at best price. Visit now to get exclusive offers on Tour Packages ..https://sulekhaholidays.com https://sulekhaholidays.com