5 ms·
Does anyone else find this sort of thing super depressing? When I lived in New York and happened to travel outside the state, I'd regularly get people I ran ac
by pmoriarty 7y ago
Does anyone else find this sort of thing super depressing?
When I lived in New York and happened to travel outside the state, I'd regularly get people I ran across telling me how surprised they were to hear that I was from New York, because I was so nice and their impression (despite usually never having set foot in New York) was that New Yorkers were assholes.
I told them that virtually everyone I ran across in New York was nice, but that it was a gigantic city and there were all sorts of people there, and because of that it's really not fair to paint all New Yorkers with such a broad brush.
I'd get similar reactions when I traveled abroad and revealed to people that I was from America. One person even told me that they thought every American carried a gun. I had to tell them that, no, actually no one I knew owned a gun, the majority of Americans nation-wide did not own a gun, and it was a country of 300 million people of all sorts, many from other countries and of many different cultures, different politics, different views of the world. It's really not fair to paint all Americans with one broad brush.
So now I hear that in Idaho simply being from California (a state with a population of 40 million people) could get you painted with a broad brush in Idaho. It just seems so petty, insular, xenophobic, and close minded. Wouldn't the world be better if we welcomed those who are different from us, at least as long as they also wanted to live with us in peace?
Maybe mine's considered a stereotypically Californian attitude that would get me pounded down in Idaho. If so, that's just really sad.
- jakeogh 7y agoThere's nothing wrong with having effective tools to protect life. If people know you have an irrational fear of some object, they just wont tell you. I live in Tucson, we have _plenty_ of guns, but in general, we carry them conceiled. There's no pemission slip. Weapons are the ultimate form of equality, they prevent the strong from ruling the weak. Places where only the criminals are armed are totally different.
- matchbok 7y ago> Weapons are the ultimate form of equality ...only if everyone is willing to carry? The lack of understanding here is astounding. The claim of lax gun laws promotes safety has been debunked hundreds of times. The average person does not have to have to carry a firearm in order to be safe, believe it or not. It's sad, really, how people think owning guns makes them safer or more tough. Statistically the former is 100% not true. Maybe people have this fiction in their heads that they will "save the day" from the bad guy (or government?) Seems childish.
- jakeogh 7y agoTell that to a single mother. It's not your choice. It's a false argument that everyone needs to carry. Hence police get phone calls... to bring guns. Are you going to politely ask the murderer to wait 5 minutes? Nice "stats" you have there. http://v6y.net/gun_stats.jpg http://v6y.net/gun_stats.jpg
- lern_too_spel 7y agoGP didn't offer meaningless "stats" like your link. They simply noted that relaxing gun laws like allowing concealed carry leads to an increase in violent crime under every analysis. https://www.rand.org/research/gun-policy/analysis/concealed-carry.html https://www.rand.org/research/gun-policy/analysis/concealed-... presents a survey of the research.
- jakeogh 7y agoEverything on that graphic is sourced at the bottom. Right from your link: "NO STUDIES MET OUR CRITERIA" -> "Defensive Gun Use" Obviously they need to avoid that given the first thing on the graphic. Even skipping the biggest stat, they honestly admit "limited" and "inconclusive" on the table's 4th row: https://www.rand.org/research/gun-policy/analysis.html https://www.rand.org/research/gun-policy/analysis.html "increase in violent crime under every analysis" the table you linked to says "limited", and the criteria for limited is "At least one study meeting our inclusion criteria ". So by "every analysis" you mean "at least one study".
- lern_too_spel 7y agoYour graphic is a bunch of disconnected statistics with no causal analysis. It doesn't even run a regression, which would easily find other explanations for what it so incompetently implies. There's a reason it's a social media graphic instead of published research.
- jakeogh 7y ago
- bassman9000 7y agoWhich brings us to the heart of the problem: income inequality. Anyone moving to Boise from another part of Idaho is still saddled with the same bottom-of-the-barrel minimum wage, an anemic $7.25 an hour. So it’s most likely not the Idahoans who are driving up home prices and filling up rental properties, because they can’t afford to. Then Californians arrive, raise prices in ways the locals can't compete against, and vote the same policies they enacted in California, which they don't recognize (due to some cognitive bias) as the same ones that caused them to leave. That's depressing. Specially to locals. They're powerless as they see their way of life challenged. And then you call them insular, xenophonic, and close minded. Wouldn't the world be better if we welcomed those who are different from us, at least as long as they also wanted to live with us in peace? FTFA “I’m not here to be a Californian,” she said. “I’m here to be a community member and contribute.” I'm pretty sure if you're moving to adapt, to become one of them, to respect the locals and their ways, you're going to be welcome. Probably, and this is MHO, better than in NY or California. edit: formatting