3 ms·
> It would be more useful if Greenspun had, as he's the one who should carry the burden of proof in this case. I can see your point...as long unemployment bene
by mistermann 16y ago
> It would be more useful if Greenspun had, as he's the one who should carry the burden of proof in this case.
I can see your point...as long unemployment benefits are the current status-quo, and they are, that someone questioning this should carry the burden of proof. I can appreciate this line of thinking.
Another way of thinking about it....if there is a forceful, non-voluntary, ongoing transfer of money from one group of people to another group, should the recipients of the money, or their advocates, not have some obligation (on an ongoing basis), to justify the aggregate benefits to society of this wealth transfer? Can you appreciate this line of thinking, at all?
Don't confuse this with me suggesting the unemployed should be cut off and thrown out on the street. I'm simply trying to point out that it seems to offend some people if anyone merely suggests we have a discussion on the relative merits of various kinds of social welfare.
I'd also like to point out that I am of the opinion that in the aggregate, there might be A LOT more money going in the other direction, especially lately.