2 ms·
Throwaway; Response posted in case someone Google this and find this thread (Happy to see this is off the front page as this type of content doesn't belong on H
by 908B64B197 7y ago
Throwaway; Response posted in case someone Google this and find this thread (Happy to see this is off the front page as this type of content doesn't belong on HN).
What's interesting with this story is to see the different media coverage it received in French and English media. The French ones gave a little more context into why her application was initially denied. Basically she didn't fill the application properly.
I've known multiple people who used the exact same program as her to immigrate. There is no language requirement for courses or thesis. However, having followed all courses in French and written a full thesis in French removes the requirement to pass a standardized French test (think TOEFL). According to the CBC article in French[1] she was warned when she started writing it that unless she translated the chapters written in English she would potentially have to pass the Standardized French test as it wouldn't be adequate to waive the requirement for a test. She ignored this warning and decided to submit her application anyways.
Later, as warned by the university officials, she received a request for evidence. She either had to pass a Standardized test OR demonstrate three years of high school level education in French (from the folks that I know who went through this, a simple copy of a French high school transcript is good enough).
She had two months to give a response but apparently waited 4 months (it's not completely obvious from the article and completely omitted from the English CBC news one [2]) to respond.
The ultimate reason why she was denied is never explicitly stated. It seems that she switched jobs while her application was pending and became a freelance illustrator. The immigration program she applied for specifically prohibits self-employment. Either that or she sent the required evidence too late and they closed her file.
tl;dr : Her paperwork was incomplete. She was warned several times and ignored a request for evidence for several months & switched to a job specifically not covered by the immigration program she was applying to.
Case closed.
[1] https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1378665/immigration-quebec-francaise-refusee-chapitre-doctorat-anglais-universite-laval https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1378665/immigration-que...
[2] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/french-thesis-immigration-caq-1.5351155 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/french-thesis-immigr...