2 ms·
Wasn't that "10,000 hrs of practice to master anything" paper discredited? This one sounds very similar in trying to quantify a very chaotic and qualitative pro
by dmix 7y ago
Wasn't that "10,000 hrs of practice to master anything" paper discredited? This one sounds very similar in trying to quantify a very chaotic and qualitative process. The usefulness of such a stat on any one person is probably nil.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Wasn't that "10,000 hrs of practice to master anything" paper discredited? No, AFAIK it literally never existed. That was, as I recall, a popular misinterpretation of what was itself an unwarranted generalization made by Malcolm Gladwell based on a paper with much more limited scope and conclusions. > This one sounds very similar in trying to quantify a very chaotic and qualitative process. The actual direct conclusion—that this error rate is optimal for a variety of machine-learning processes—does not seem to ha r the problem you describe. The suggestion in the paper that this extends to “biologically plausible” neural networks that may model animal learning also does not seem problematic in the way you describe. The news article’s claim that this is a finding of a sweet spot for human learning is, while it is a possibility suggested by the paper, simply unwarranted as a conclusion. It's certainly plausible that a quantifiable sweet spot of this type exists for some kinds of human learning at the optimization of effectiveness in a curriculum that can be dynamically scaled to individual learners could effectively be guided by it, but there is not a strong reason without actually testing in concrete human learning scenarios to believe that the particular number here is a guide to that.