10 ms·
I've seen the effects of "rational social planning" by the enlightened and would rather go with the flawed individual freedom crowd.
by protomyth 16y ago
I've seen the effects of "rational social planning" by the enlightened and would rather go with the flawed individual freedom crowd.
- borism 16y agobut have you seen the effects of "rational social planning" by the unenlightened?
- protomyth 16y agoThey said they were enlightened, but I admit to having my doubts.
- hessenwolf 16y agoI grew up in a socially-planned town. The problem is in the practicalities of the execution of a large project, by people who just consider it a day job, competing against the corrupting influence of local personal interest. The product of the planning wasn't exactly a macbook pro.
- steveklabnik 16y agoYou do understand that he's not speaking of a centrally planned government, right? Chomsky specifically advocates as close to direct democracy as possible.
- protomyth 16y agoI didn't get that from the above quote, but I haven't read Chomsky. I just have quite a bit of problems with people believing that the group is always right compared to the individual, and I got the group vibe from the above. I admit my interpretation could be in error.
- steveklabnik 16y agoNo worries, I haven't read as much Chomsky as I should either. His views are obviously nuanced, but he's most often described as an anarcho-syndiclist: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho_syndicalism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho_syndicalism The main problem with your interpretation is not that the group is better than the individual, but that then the group _imposes_ that view upon the individual. There's a big difference between cooperative decision making and a dictatorship by an 'enlightened few.'
- waqf 16y ago> I haven't read as much Chomsky as I should either. [emphasis added] See?! Now they've convinced you that to be fulfilled you have to read Chomsky!
- steveklabnik 16y agoI should. I should read lots of things. Reading more is good for you. However, in this case, what I meant was, "I really should read more Chomsky before attempting to claim that I am fully and accurately representing his viewpoint in an argument."