3 ms·
You’re merely making an argument from authority, not responding to anything I wrote. Furthermore, that blog post is both old (and itself refers to even older r
by teddyh 7y ago
You’re merely making an argument from authority, not responding to anything I wrote.
Furthermore, that blog post is both old (and itself refers to even older references to back up its claims, and has a large discussion of now-fixed issues in DNSSEC) and it also presents an incomplete list of reasons for why DANE might be wanted. It is ignoring DANE’s HTST-like feature of signalling that HTTPS must be used, to prevent protocol downgrade attacks, which is exactly the reason we are discussing DANE here.
- tptacek 7y agoI can no longer keep track of what you're trying to argue. The chain-extensions debacle is less than a year old. It was motivated by the same concerns as the AGL article. Since you acknowledged upthread not being aware of chain-extensions in the first place, despite it being a big-ticket issue for DANE deployment (enough for Geoff Huston to write a whole article bemoaning its failure as a standard) I'm not sure from where you're drawing the certitude that these issues aren't real.
- teddyh 7y agoAnd now you’re arguing Ad hominem in addition to argument from authority, and still not actually responding. I think we’re done here.