3 ms·
It’s been a solved problem from the time it launched: you should never have one FIDO device since that leaves no room for failure. Every service I use except Am
by acdha 7y ago
It’s been a solved problem from the time it launched: you should never have one FIDO device since that leaves no room for failure. Every service I use except Amazon implemented this correctly[1] and the significant security improvements over TOTP or SSH keys are worth it, especially since phishing operations commonly bypass the easier schemes now.
1. You’ll need to find a notary if you lose your AWS MFA device
- jlokier 7y agoI wouldn't be comfortable with one backup device kept in secure storage somewhere. If it fails you won't know, and you'll be operating without redundancy without knowing. So that means keeping two or more devices in regular use. Somehow, without carrying them both around or keeping them in the same places. Tricky.
- acdha 7y agoIt means testing your backups and knowing what your unlock procedure is like — for example, can another administrator at your company perform that reset for you? This doesn't need to be something you do daily so you can schedule it but this is a classic security tradeoff: if you're not comfortable with the odds of multiple hardware devices simultaneously failing, you can simply decide to accept the greater security risk of using shared SSH keys or whatever you're using to manage passwords.