3 ms·
There was a time in the medival ages where alchemists were kidnapped by kings and held in chambers so they would only generate knowledge for them. This obviousl
by atoav 7y ago
There was a time in the medival ages where alchemists were kidnapped by kings and held in chambers so they would only generate knowledge for them. This obviously lead to a similar duplication to the one you describe, right up to calculus where Newton kept the thing hidden in a drawer and then Leibnitz had the same idea.
Once that kind of secrecy was gone our whole technical progress was accelerated, because people could build on the discoveries of other people.
Right now we are going back to the alchemist model in some ways (the highest profile people work for the big companies and don’t share their discoveries). This makes progress slower.
- modeless 7y ago> the highest profile people work for the big companies and don’t share their discoveries I have to strongly disagree with this for the specific case of AI/ML. The big company labs are publishing open access papers non-stop, often with code and sometimes even datasets. They're more open than some areas of academia, in fact.
- atoav 7y agoReally? I heard the opposite from someone in the field, who told me that they do publish but it is never the really relevant stuff. I can’t really judge that myself to be honest
- doomlaser 7y agoLeon Gatys, the guy who published A Neural Algorithm for Artistic Style that revolutionized the entire industry while he was at a university is now employed at Apple. They have published at least one thing that was semi-interesting on cognitive functioning in older adults and how it can be expressed through smartphone usage: http://delivery.acm.org/10.1145/3310000/3300398/a168-gordon.html http://delivery.acm.org/10.1145/3310000/3300398/a168-gordon.... Interesting and certainly compelling, but not earth-shaking like style transfer has been.
- nl 7y agoI work in the field. New and relevant stuff is published frequently by Google, Facebook and Microsoft (as well as smaller companies like NVidia etc). Apple very occasionally publishes too.