3 ms·
So many knee-jerk “obvious” solutions in comments here, some with gratuitous violent fantasies to boot. Might I suggest that you look at how your proposed solu
by teddyh 7y ago
So many knee-jerk “obvious” solutions in comments here, some with gratuitous violent fantasies to boot. Might I suggest that you look at how your proposed solution compares to other, older, suggestion on how the then-new email spam problem used to be suggested to be fixed:
https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt
Also, this is a mostly exclusively a U.S. problem. In Europe, we basically just don’t ever get “robocalls”, and have ever only heard about them in stories from the U.S. Anyone proposing a complicated technological change should explain why this is necessary when Europe seems to have found a solution already.
- ikeboy 7y agoThere's no real email spoofing problem anymore because we have signatures proving the source on every email. There's a phone spoofing problem because carriers are allowing spoofing, when they don't have to.
- teddyh 7y ago> * There's no real email spoofing problem anymore because we have signatures proving the source on every email.* (I assume that you are referring to DKIM, and not OpenPGP or S/MIME, since the latter two are obviously not frequently used.) DKIM signatures (not to mention DMARC to actually require a signature) are not actually that common either. Spoofing is mostly still rejected by a combination of plain old SPF and spam filtering of the mail contents. All in my experience, of course. > There's a phone spoofing problem because carriers are allowing spoofing, when they don't have to. Is this what Europe is doing which the U.S. isn’t? If it is, then you’re probably right. I don’t actually know. I’m just saying that whatever Europe is doing is evidently working, and any other proposed solution would have some significant benefit and proof of efficacy to be considered over a proven concept.
- hippich 7y agoWho is paying for the incoming call in Europe (honest question)? If it is caller only - perhaps it is a reason? In my home country, where receiver of the call does not pay for the call, robocalling would be uterly unprofitable.
- GordonS 7y agoUK person here - while I can't speak for the whole of Europe, robocalls and fraudulent calls are a big problem here. At least for the fraudulent calls, they seem to exclusively come from India, so I presume they mainly target English speaking countries. Typically they claim to be from BT, Microsoft or "your ISP", and try to convince you to install dodgy software on the basis that "your computer has been sending out viruses". This software then messes up your PC or at least makes it look like it, so you shell out some cash for the fraudsters to "fix it". My understanding is that if you fall for this kind of thing, your number also gets passed on or sold to more serious fraudsters. Robocalls here for the past 5 years or so seem to mainly be from scummy ambulance-chasing solicitors ("we've been notified you were in an accident, contact us now about your claim", that kind of thing).
- shifto 7y agoI'm in Europe (NL) and get a lot of robocalls. Seems to have died down a bit nowadays in favor of fake SMS to replace my debit card but it's all the same spam to me.