4 ms·
Greenspun doesn't bear the burden of proof because he isn't trying to prove anything. He is asking a question and admitting his uncertainty: "The standard 26 we
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Greenspun doesn't bear the burden of proof because he isn't trying to prove anything. He is asking a question and admitting his uncertainty: "The standard 26 weeks of unemployment makes sense to me...But the subsequent 1.5 years don’t make sense...What’s wrong with my thinking?"
Jessriedel did the same thing: "I don't claim he was the norm. I'm just giving this anecdotal evidence to say that...we...need hard data."
You asserted the existence of evidence without providing it (potentially misleading), and then attacked the people who disagreed with you (harmful). If you have your own theory, argue it and acknowledge uncertainty (just as Greenspun and Jessriedel did). If you have facts to support your position, present them (if you do, awesome). Ad hominem attacks provide no value.
- roc 16y agoLet's take a step back. I didn't (intend to) take issue with any part of jessriedel's post. Clearly I misspoke in my reply and people were confused. My intent was to concede his point: I was not providing evidence about what unemployment looks like. I provided nothing more than my own opinion. We all agree on that. And I'm truly not interested in trying to solve political problems on the internet, so I invited him to sate his own curiosity as to what unemployment looks like. You're either interested in the issue and thus need to do your own research or you're not. If I'd used Google to scare up a link or two, that should not be sufficient for any critical and skeptical thinker. Feel free to disagree with my characterization of unemployment all you like. I invite you to. But please note that you only disagree with me, because I didn't provide any more evidence than Greenspun did. And then hopefully you'll take a moment to wonder why you're complaining about my lack of evidence, but not Greenspun's.