3 ms·
This is true but people tend to forget one thing: decommissioning doesn't necessarily means dismantling. Dismantling is a tough challenge (mainly because of the
by littlestymaar 7y ago
This is true but people tend to forget one thing: decommissioning doesn't necessarily means dismantling. Dismantling is a tough challenge (mainly because of the civil engineering part btw, which becomes difficult to manage when you add the constraints from nuclear: “What do you mean when you say we can't use dynamite? oO”) but it's only a legal obligation not an absolute one. With government support to change the law, EDF could just unload the fuel (price is well known, they do it all the time), and pickle the primary circuit in place (the price is also known, they did it a few times already) and now you have a place where all contamination (which comes from neutronic activation) is trapped inside the structure (Co60 in the rebar of the structure mostly) and the biggest risk is asbestos… (like your nearest decommissionined building in your neighborhood, even houses).
This option leaves you with a few ugly buildings in the middle of nowhere, but the cost unbeatable (even way less than decommissioning thousands of wind turbines).
- DuskStar 7y agoWhy isn't this just the default choice?
- littlestymaar 7y agoGood question. The dismantling narrative probably comes from a mix between wishful thinking from politicians and bad habits of lying all the time from the nuclear industry… I mean, the nuclear story is even brighter if we can promise we'll clean up after us right?
- eqvinox 7y ago> This option leaves you with a few ugly buildings in the middle of nowhere, but the cost unbeatable (even way less than decommissioning thousands of wind turbines). Aren't you forgetting something? Buildings slowly deteriorate, even if not used. So now you have to maintain the disused reactor, for ... how long exactly? (Amendment: wind, rain, sunlight, rodents, ... idiots with power tools ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident )
- littlestymaar 7y ago> Buildings slowly deteriorate, even if not used. So now you have to maintain the disused reactor, for ... how long exactly? And here comes radioactive decays to the rescue! Half-life of Co60 is a little bit more than 5 years, for instance. The important thing to consider is that dangerous radioactive materials are also the ones with the shortest half-life (because the same number of atoms emits more radiation per second), so as long as you took out the fuel[1] you don't have anything really dangerous for too long. It could still be a problem when decommissioning (because you spill everything out in a short time and you have workers just nearby) but if you let the building just decay slowly, you don't have issues. [1]: the fuel is a bit special, because it has long half-life but it's still dangerous for two reasons. 1) it's alpha emitters, the worst kind of radioactive substance. 2) the concentration is enormous.
- eqvinox 7y agoCo-60 isn't the only side product though. A quick Google search yields me https://mitnse.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/radiation_npp_07.pdf https://mitnse.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/radiation_npp_07.... which lists: Krypton-85 Beta/Gamma 10 years Strontium-90 Beta 28 years Iodine-131 Beta/Gamma 8 days Cesium-137 Beta/Gamma 30 years Carbon-14 Beta 5770 years Zinc-65 Beta/Gamma 245 days Cobalt-60 Beta/Gamma 5 years Iron-59 Beta/Gamma 45 days Tritium Beta 12 years I'm also not sure where you got the idea that alpha emitters are the worst kind of radioactive substance; alpha radiation is easily shielded. On the other hand, sure, just leaving the reactor there for 50 years may be part of a cost effective solution. https://www.dndkm.org/DOEKMDocuments/BestPractices/26-EFCOG%20Best%20Practice%20-%20SRS%20P%20and%20R%20Reactor%20Basins%20ISD%20Final.pdf https://www.dndkm.org/DOEKMDocuments/BestPractices/26-EFCOG%... (linked from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_decommissioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_decommissioning) claims a 71% reduction in decomissioning costs. However, this includes neither fuel waste disposal costs nor future costs for full dismantling at some point.
- belorn 7y agoThe parent talk about how the building material like rebars absorbs the isotopes, and then how long it can afterward be harmful. Do those isotopes also get absorbed, and if so, at what rate? Since I don't know the physic I don't know if all isotopes can get absorbed at the same rate, but my intuition is that the answer is no. I would also guess that nuclear plants get exposed to different amount of each type of isotope, so the above table would need to include both in order to compare the radiation risk after X years.
- Lev1a 7y agoExample of one nuclear power plant being decommissioned (German TV documentary, Spring 2018): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpUjNayFJvM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpUjNayFJvM
- freeflight 7y ago> decommissioning doesn't necessarily means dismantling That's kinda missing the point, the fact is that France's nuclear fleet is heavily underfunded by at least 50 billion Euro [0]. These are exactly the kind of costs regularly externalized or completely omitted when calculating the profitability of nuclear vs renewables [1]. [0] https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-europe-nuclear/eu-short-of-118-billion-euros-in-nuclear-decommissioning-funds-draft-idUKKCN0VP2KN https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-europe-nuclear/eu-short-of... [1] https://energypost.eu/how-profitable-is-an-investment-in-nuclear-power/ https://energypost.eu/how-profitable-is-an-investment-in-nuc...