3 ms·
The fight against tobacco grew into a very large and lucrative industry consisting of a lot of lawyers and nonprofits; experts and pharmaceutical companies with
by pessimizer 7y ago
The fight against tobacco grew into a very large and lucrative industry consisting of a lot of lawyers and nonprofits; experts and pharmaceutical companies with smoking cessation products and programs; and employing a lot of lobbyists, government grant writers, and PR people.
After the big tobacco settlements were done and the restrictions on advertising, packaging, flavoring, and describing cigarettes made federal law, this industry was decimated. The people left behind simply look for any possibility of generating income from anything they can connect to cigarette consumption.
I honestly think it's purely venal. They're attacking a product with a tiny health risk as compared to cigarettes, but using the same language and intentionally and carefully equivocating between the health effects of the two. If they were actually concerned about people's health, the emphasis would be on lobbying for regulation, inspection, and testing of vaping products - which have been a complete free-for-all of an industry which was long overdue to have killed people with a run of tainted product. That it happened in the corner case of vaping and cannabis made it even less overseen, but was also probably a bit of good luck. More people vape tobacco and people who vape tobacco vape more. If some new (or old) ingredient in some widely-distributed line of "vape juice" turned out to be killing people, it would kill a lot more people. That has nothing to do with nicotine or tobacco, though, the reason we even have an FDA is because of dangerous cosmetics, so I don't know how things like "supplements" and vape juice get defined as unregulatable other than through bribery. And I don't know why these groups fight for ultimately unattainable bans rather than proper, strict regulation other than that going for bans generates endless work. If vaping is safer than cigarettes then we want smokers to vape, and if vaping can be made absolutely safe by changing how it's made and inspecting what is sold, then we should do that and as a society stop telling people not to vape.
NPR is simply pushing the agenda of whoever is willing to give it money and send it press releases, and that's probably a lot of law firms looking for a new tobacco-style feeding frenzy and a bunch of government regulators and counterpart lobbyists considering collaborating on that. I would guess that there may have been internal lobbying at some point that would keep NPR from accepting money from tobacco companies anyway, and Altria isn't part of Kraft any more, so there's really no avenue for them to have a say in NPR content.