8 ms·
Narcissistic CEOs weaken collaboration and integrity
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoI always think it's good that people research things that are considered "obvious" because there is always that rare chance you will discover something unexpected! That said, nothing interesting was really discovered here - the article does go into a bit more detail but you can really summarize it as "people don't like to work with assholes, and people especially don't like to work for assholes"
- erik_landerholm 7y agoHmmm...my experience is very different. A lot of seemingly normal people are just fine, if not happy to be led by psychopaths and narcissists. They view their "confidence" as a plus because they don't dig deeply or are just scared, wimps and like a big strong "asshole" to lead them. I honestly blame the rise of asshole CEO's and leaders on the normies, who don't want to be be held accountable.
- taberiand 7y agoPeople follow the path of least resistance - it's easier for most people to play the office politics game where the boss will let them than do the work before them. It's still a failure of management and leadership however.
- zozbot234 7y agoIt's not happiness, it's complacency. Huge difference. Psychopaths and narcissists do a LOT of unseen damage if not kept under a very tight leash.
- philwelch 7y agoConfidence and assertiveness are important leadership traits. I don't know what's considered "seemingly normal", but different people can make radically different judgments of character, and a lot of narcissists can exploit this. People who can and do reliably detect psychopaths and narcissists tend to develop an aversion.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoThis is the truth about leadership. As long as everyone is getting their due, few will care about the overt sociopathy of the leader and those that do will have no political power to change it. That's one truth I had to discover via experience and it destroyed my morale and idealism.
- firstplacelast 7y agoI agree here 200%. People may not want to be “the asshole”, but they want to work under “the asshole” because they think it will benefit them and help them get what they want because their leaders are willing to be cutthroat, which may benefit them.
- wpietri 7y agoIf it were all that obvious, we wouldn't have so many abusive narcissists in positions of power. I'll leave politics aside, but just taking companies in the news this week, we can look at Adam Neumann and Travis Kalanick as narcissists who couldn't even get a company to IPO due to failures of collaboration and integrity. The article correctly points out some of the direct economic damage. It ignores the significant damage to people done by abusive narcissists; from personal experience I can say it's substantial. You can see that in the interviews with WeWork employees. But another kind of damage is what they prevent from existing. Kalanick was aggressive in killing competition; Lyft was the only one he couldn't spend into the grave. Neumann has deeply distorted the market for coworking. Or we could look at Zuckerberg [1]; what kind of open social networks could we have ended up with if he hadn't ruthlessly pursued a personally-dominated monopoly? [1] http://www.afterpsychotherapy.com/narcissistic-personality-disorder/ http://www.afterpsychotherapy.com/narcissistic-personality-d...
- mschuster91 7y ago> But another kind of damage is what they prevent from existing. At least for VC-backed direct competition, nothing of value is lost. The business is commodity - driving people around in cars, delivering food, renting office space, offering rides on e-scooters, running under-the-table hotels, whatever. All that the insane amounts of VC enable is network effects and marketplace dominance - people don't call a pizza shop or a cab company any more, they open the Delivery Hero or Uber apps. But someone still has to make the pizza or drive the cab, which means until fully automated driving is reality, there is no direct loss in jobs. The more interesting things are rather the "competition" that is entrenched companies... most obvious in taxis. Usually, taxis are regulated (meaning, their cars have appropriate insurance, silent alarm devices in case the driver gets robbed, and most importantly mandatory service areas and times). Uber/Lyft etc. can now pick the profitable cherries (airport transfers, drunk partygoers on Friday/Saturday) and leave the unprofitable times or areas to the regular cabs - who cannot run at an overall profit anymore as the business/hipster clientele is now using Uber/Lyft. Who suffers? Entire communities now underserved by taxis, old people (who don't have smartphones)... but no one really looks at which negative impact his/her company will have on minorities.
- 7y ago
- dreamcompiler 7y agoNarcissists are a specific kind of asshole. They tend to seek power and they are very good at convincing the people above them that they deserve it. That's what makes them more dangerous to an organization than average assholes.
- tempsy 7y agoIsn't narcissism among those who rise to an executive rank at some point in their career more the norm rather than the exception?
- warent 7y agoI've always thought that was more of a meme/rumor than actual fact. It seems unlikely to me that the average executive is somebody with a fragile ego that lacks empathy. From my perspective it can't be the case. The executives I've worked with have always been powerful teammates with great listening/communication skills. Maybe I'm just lucky?
- jjtheblunt 7y agoI'm also lucky, then.
- rriepe 7y agoNarcissists conduct abuse within intimate (romantic, familial or very close friends) relationships. Outside of those relationships, they're typically very well-behaved and even adored.
- xiaolingxiao 7y agocould you expand on this? why do they do this?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mjfl 7y agoWhen I read a description of a narcissist, I think "that sounds like the description of an average human to me".
- jdc 7y agoWell it is a tragically common trait these days.
- jacquesm 7y agoInstagram and Facebook really fuel that trend.
- throwaway35784 7y agoTragically all the narcissists are on there with their selfies hopelessly looking for love from all the other narcissists psychologically unable to give it.
- bilbo0s 7y agoThere was a time it was not so common a trait. I distinctly remember the 70's and 80's when there were a large number of people who I would say "lacked confidence" so to speak. Kind of unsure of themselves, shy and retiring types. As we moved into the 21st century, it does seem like lack of confidence has gone away. People are almost "over confident" sometimes.
- cj 7y ago> People are almost "over confident" sometimes. Is it possible that people are by and large the same, but that social media simply makes it very easy for people lacking confidence to come across as more confident than they really are?
- ashelmire 7y agoI suspect it's more that the very confident have their messages amplified on social media. Most people I encounter in person are not like that.
- jjtheblunt 7y ago"Narcissists weaken collaboration and integrity." works as a more general title, I suspect.
- hervature 7y agoExtrapolating from 700 mechanical Turk surveys to CEO behavior seems like quite the leap.
- bryanmgreen 7y agoAre you purposely excluding the "250 MBA students taking coauthor Chatman’s course on leadership at UC Berkeley" plus the "nearly 900 business school alumni from Stanford, Santa Clara University, and UC Berkeley who worked at 56 large, publicly traded high-tech firms based in the United States"?
- hervature 7y agoNot on purpose, stopped reading after that line about mechanical Turk. Still, after reading the whole study, I can't believe this is publishable.
- bryanmgreen 7y agoI probably would have left out that mechanical Turk data, if only for perception. The rest seems quite solid.
- cryptica 7y agoI definitely agree with the premise of the article that narcissism takes away value instead of adding value. Being calculative, cold and even disloyal at an individual level does not make someone a narcissist, it can be a very altruistic and idealistic thing in fact. For example, firing untalented employees to make room for more talented, hard working ones is altruistic IMO. If everyone did this, the system would work really well and everyone would be better off (even the lazy, untalented people would be better off thanks to universal improvements in productivity). I think nepotism is a huge problem now. At scale, loyalty to specific individuals can be downright evil. Loyalty must only be given on the basis of shared values and principles. Criminals can be extremely loyal to each other but they have no shared values aside from mutual self-preservation.
- guest2143 7y agoThe only defense social humans have is really to detect them. Watch for their inability to feel empathy. Ask them to tell a joke. Do they do it right? http://hintjens.com/blog:_psychopaths http://hintjens.com/blog:_psychopaths
- Moto7451 7y agoMy personal experience is that this applies to any C suite member.
- xenihn 7y agoIt applies to anyone who can't be fired easily.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nrjames 7y agoI’m about to go through a series of job interviews. Any tips on determining whether potential future managers or coworkers are narcissists? Seems like it can be hard to suss this out without some longer-term exposure.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoNarcissists see others as extensions of themselves, take credit and pass the blame. A red flag is when you cannot make a distinction between your personal achievements and your team achievements.
- cagenut 7y agoCorrect or confront them on literally anything.
- postfacto 7y agoNarcissists are very charming initially and very good at hiding it. Some tells: - Very attuned to their own fashion attire. Very well/trendy dressed. - Use the words/phrases “value”, “add value” - Brag about themselves a lot. Talk about very lofty standards about very minor details.
- zozbot234 7y ago>and very good at hiding it Not really, you just need to know what to look for. A shallow, materialistic person with very little sense of humor, curiosity of the social/intellectual/cultural/creative kind, or visibly empathetic interest in others is a big red flag. The "curiosity" part may well be the easiest to assess as an observer, because it's not something that can be faked easily.
- proverbialbunny 7y agoNone of those criteria fits NPD, except that they're good at hiding it. Only a few kinds of narcissists are charming.
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoAnecdata: I have adopted a heuristic from experience that so far has a 100% success rate in detecting psych issues in women: Women that majored in Psychology are women you dont want in your life. Make of that what you will.
- bryanmgreen 7y agoI like that the semi-obvious research is being done because it moves the conversation forward and helps avoid complacency and shrugging-of-shoulders. Changing the status-quo can be about mindsets, not just product. Next step is focusing on solutions for/around narcissist leaders. Also great to see Hacker News supporting these non-engineering business topics as well.
- throw138away 7y agoRecent experience has led me to wonder whether narcissistic founders are more likely to succeed. Their self-confidence makes them less likely to give up. When they they have some success through luck or effort from others they will attribute the success to themselves and keep going, creating a positive feedback loop for themselves, but a pretty toxic environment for everyone else involved. Any employees questioning the narcissist will have a bad time.
- dang 7y agoHow did they identify who was a narcissist in order to study their effects? I didn't think there was an objective test for that.
- bryanmgreen 7y agoI think they describe it here: "They asked more than 250 MBA students taking coauthor Chatman’s course on leadership at UC Berkeley to provide names for at least three current or former coworkers, who then confidentially rated the students on measures of narcissism." And here: "Researchers surveyed nearly 900 business school alumni... who worked at 56 large, publicly traded high-tech firms... Alumni completed surveys to evaluate their CEO’s personality type and organizational cultures." Sure it's a little subjective like anything based on societal norms, but there are generally accepted behavior models/characteristics around personality types across medical fields.
- peteradio 7y ago> accepted behavior models/characteristics around personality types across medical fields Of which probably none of those surveyed are trained to recognize. Heres a typical response: My boss is an asshole thats why everything went to shit. Is he narcissist? Oh yea big time.
- bryanmgreen 7y agoThe surveyed aren’t, but the surveyors are. And I imagine the questions were nuanced and sophisticated enough that they weren’t as basic “is your boss an asshole” and more like “on a scale of 1 being Spock to 10 being Trump, how does your boss handle conflict?”
- new_realist 7y agoTesla would make a good case study here.
- timwaagh 7y agoThe only thing important for a CEO is their effect on bottom line and stock price. If the effect is that people collaborate less, but results go up, maybe more collaboration is not necessarily always positive. So in my opinion, just using these metrics and no economical metrics gives no useful answer for those who need to hire a CEO. On a further note, the tendency to blame things on other people's personality types is akin to a modern-day astrology.
- RangerScience 7y ago> The only thing important for a CEO is their effect on bottom line and stock price. What? No. Legally that may be true for C-corps, but AFAIK that's explicitly why people started doing B-corps; to have other metrics of success than just those two. And even for C-corps, doesn't it still depend on what the shareholders want? And after all that, you've still got to consider that if you're only looking at "ends justify means", well, why do you think you're at an end and can even measure it?
- fosstax 7y agoIgnoring the ethics of hiring someone that almost certainly will cause psychological trauma to their colleagues, I just want to say that narcissism is hardly a "personality type".
- dwaltrip 7y agoWhat time scale? The bottom line next quarter? 3 years from now? 10 years from now? 20 years from now? If it is impossible to plan precisely enough to determine the bottom line 20 years from now, perhaps fostering a dynamic, healthy culture with a powerful vision is a more effective way of creating a successful company than narrowly looking only at the amount of profits. Obviously, the business model must be considered. But a business model with no value system or vision will likely crumble as conditions change.
- crispyambulance 7y ago> The only thing important for a CEO is their effect on bottom line and stock price... People are just tired of assholery, ok. It's not like greed is new. It's always been a part of human experience, usually bad, and especially so when it becomes extractive and monopolistic. But there's something about "tech" startups that seems to attract the most awful personalities into c-level leadership. I expect railroad and oil tycoons were much the same in their day. I don't expect anything to be different in the tech industry.
- alexfromapex 7y agoAny narcissistic exec weakens these things. We had a CIO that came into the startup I was at and just destroyed the culture.
- foobar_ 7y agoYeah, loser narcissists are the worst. Pay very little. Fake worse than the Kardashians. Lie, manipulate, bullshit, boast, play favourites at every turn at every turn.