6 ms·
Why is the media, continuously and erroneously tying tainted THC cartridges with flavored nicotine vapes targeting children? It's not just one time either. Th
by colordrops 7y ago
Why is the media, continuously and erroneously tying tainted THC cartridges with flavored nicotine vapes targeting children? It's not just one time either. There's an interstitial on NPR which offers an informational website about the dangers of flavored nicotine to address the toxic cartridges. It's completely illogical, which makes me think that some sponsor is pushing an agenda.
- whamlastxmas 7y agoTobacco companies want to kill vaping and replace it with heated tobacco. They're pushing this.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoI don't think that's fair to assume - PMI for sure is pushing heated tobacco and making major gains with it's IQOS product but Altria owns a massive stake in JUUL and most tobacco companies now have their own vaping products. My guess, but it's just a guess, is that tobacco companies just want new products like yesteryears "low tar" and "filtered" cigarettes that lure people into thinking something is healthier and either start or put off quitting
- whamlastxmas 7y agoTobacco companies own vaping products but they don't want to. They'd rather lose their entire vaping line and go back to tobacco because it's tremendously more profitable and they have much more control over that.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAny articles or data on the statement about them not wanting to own vaping products? I recently read PMIs and BATs quarterly reports (and last years reports as well) and they're both talking up their novel products as a new source of growth as they're getting hammered on traditional tobacco. I mean I'm sure they'd like the world to just stop taxing/regulating cigarettes and everyone forget that it kills you and stay in that business forever but that just doesn't seem like a market reality
- dr_dshiv 7y agoVaping is taking a much bigger hammering than cigarettes this year. Can you imagine owning a vape shop in Massachusetts when the governor just said, boom, it's illegal -- while cigarettes get sold next door? https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2019/10/04/massachusetts-vaping-ban-shops-closed https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2019/10/04/massachusetts-vap...
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoHa, yeah that's true, this year has been rough for vaping, but the general trend for the years prior was that it wasn't quite as hated as tobacco. But I don't think the blowback has been so strong elsewhere, I've been spending a lot of time in Ukraine and I think generally the news is pretty positive even for IQOS which from my understanding from the research that's out there is likely worse than vaping and closer to the harm level of traditional cigarettes Plus just from a technical perspective because the devices aren't 'cigarettes' they're usually taxed and regulated differently, if at all, by many countries that already have high taxes and rules for cigarettes, so this is an opportunity to establish a new product category, get new customers for a few years at inflated profits because of the loose taxes and regulations, and then back to business as usual then rinse and repeat with the next generation of products
- teknologist 7y agoThe "heat not burn" systems that big tobacco companies have been pushing as a vaping alternative recently seem like they would be better sellers than cigarettes. They appear to use less materials and cause their users to consume more as they don't smell anywhere near as much (can be used anywhere) and are simply more convenient in general. Users also end up smoking more as there's a short time window to use a stick.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoNot just tobacco companies, but the antitobacco industry -- it's a collaboration of mutual interest. Plus, a lot of parents are freaking out about teen vaping. Now they have a way to say "don't do it, or you might die".
- beshrkayali 7y agoThis. Basically it's the only solid option (imo) that I've seen can help smokers easily quit. I was a smoker for ~10 years and have quit because vaping helped me control and phase out the habit. Marlboro bought juul to kill it, and taint vaping reputation along with, or at least to regulate the F out of it so that only they can continue and kill indie competition.
- brokensegue 7y agoStudies haven't shown vaping to be more effective than other techniques
- ddingus 7y agoSoon they will. Great flavored vapes have been taking people off smokes in droves. Source: Newport rep talk over a couple beers. Big tobacco is charting this and can see it big time. They have people all over the place basically identifying premium brand smokers, offering them significant incentives and definitely notice when they are gone. Their most potent, hard to kick, premium bans took a big hit when nicotine salt vape also hit. Juul showed the way. Right now there are tons of smaller players. Big tobacco wants them gone and people on to something more habit forming.
- brokensegue 7y agomany people are doing both tobacco and ecigs which would reduce tobacco sales but not result in cessation of smoking.
- ddingus 7y agoThat may be true, but the number of people no longer smoking tobacco is way up, starting about when both nicotine salt and more compelling flavors hit the scene. In general, big tobacco differentiates between less and quit. The quit numbers stand right out. For example, regular smoker gets theirs consistently at store X. Sometimes store X sells to several regular smokers. Gets price break Y to encourage and solidify that behavior. Assuming pack a day numbers, the difference between doing less and people quitting altogether tends to stand out over a bit of time. It's quantized. As to why? I am not convinced flavors had quite the impact nicotine salt did. It's significant though. Some people need something very different from tobacco, and that's where flavors seem to matter. Both seem to need that "hit" where intake of nicotine is competitive with tobacco. Juul actually adds an acid that takes habit forming to a level competitive with tobacco, and that's combined with nicotine salt, which is absorbed more readily than freebase nicotine is. Just nicotine salt, whatever flavor, is almost as potent as what Juul sells. Many cannot tell the difference, or just don't care as it's good enough for them. Typical move is to do both, and the negative experiences from tobacco add up pretty quick. Smell, having to manage flames, ashes, etc... The positives from vaping add up too. Minor league smell, if any, no management of flames, ashes. But, there is charging and the fiddling with various bits. Within a few days, depending on how impacted the smoker is, breathing differences show up, and that seals the deal for impacted smokers. Otherwise, it's just positives outweighing negatives. Cost is a fraction of tobacco, unless one is using Juul at retail. That can be par. Does not have to be. People using juice and their vapor delivery device of choice are going to pay much less.
- grandmczeb 7y agoWhat evidence is there that tobacco companies are been behind the anti-vaping movement? I’d love to be proven wrong, but as far as I can tell the only reason people say this is because they’re an easy whipping boy. IMO, it’s primarily driven by a crusade of parents and real anti tobacco groups (e.g. Tobacco Free CA.)
- eurasiantiger 7y agoTobacco addiction is about monoamine oxidase inhibition and its tendency to make nicotine extremely habit-forming. Tobacco smoke contains various MAO-inhibiting chemicals, which are the primary reinforcing agent. Vapes do not contain monoamine oxidase inhibitors, only nicotine. They are significantly less habit-forming, and the tobacco companies know this. Edit: except Juuls, which are tobacco extract vaporizers and almost certainly contain MAO inhibitors.
- grandmczeb 7y agoThat's not evidence, that's a motive. On the other hand it's a fact that tobacco companies have spent money on campaigns against various e-cigarette bans[1] and publicly argued against them as well[2]. [1] https://www.opensecrets.org/news/issues/e-cigarettes https://www.opensecrets.org/news/issues/e-cigarettes [2] https://prospect.org/health/big-tobacco-lobbied-to-save-vaping-juul-altria/ https://prospect.org/health/big-tobacco-lobbied-to-save-vapi...
- samdunham 7y agoThere's not really any evidence, but it's easy to draw a line between when the media hysteria whipped up and when the tobacco industry got approval to sell their heated tobacco product in the US. Also, there's every reason to believe that the tobacco industry would hugely benefit from vaping (an industry they have a small chunk of) going away and being replaced with heated tobacco (an industry they would own).
- meej 7y agoThe FDA really wants flavored nicotine vapes banned, like flavored tobacco was banned ten years ago. I think the tainted THC vapes are being used as a convenient excuse to do so.
- ddingus 7y agoI agree with this. Big tobacco won't mind either. That all favors heated, but not burned tobacco products they would like to see used here in the US. They are already a thing in Asia.
- Rapzid 7y agoI've been suspicious of a few agendas on NPR. That's one, another is putting the brakes on legalization. They had that Refer Madness 2.0 book guy on within the past year selling FUD. The way they setup a lot of these interviews/segments without people on representing a coherent counter point is suspicious to me to say the least. EDIT: Derailing some form of universal healthcare is another one I'm suspicious of.
- pessimizer 7y agoThe fight against tobacco grew into a very large and lucrative industry consisting of a lot of lawyers and nonprofits; experts and pharmaceutical companies with smoking cessation products and programs; and employing a lot of lobbyists, government grant writers, and PR people. After the big tobacco settlements were done and the restrictions on advertising, packaging, flavoring, and describing cigarettes made federal law, this industry was decimated. The people left behind simply look for any possibility of generating income from anything they can connect to cigarette consumption. I honestly think it's purely venal. They're attacking a product with a tiny health risk as compared to cigarettes, but using the same language and intentionally and carefully equivocating between the health effects of the two. If they were actually concerned about people's health, the emphasis would be on lobbying for regulation, inspection, and testing of vaping products - which have been a complete free-for-all of an industry which was long overdue to have killed people with a run of tainted product. That it happened in the corner case of vaping and cannabis made it even less overseen, but was also probably a bit of good luck. More people vape tobacco and people who vape tobacco vape more. If some new (or old) ingredient in some widely-distributed line of "vape juice" turned out to be killing people, it would kill a lot more people. That has nothing to do with nicotine or tobacco, though, the reason we even have an FDA is because of dangerous cosmetics, so I don't know how things like "supplements" and vape juice get defined as unregulatable other than through bribery. And I don't know why these groups fight for ultimately unattainable bans rather than proper, strict regulation other than that going for bans generates endless work. If vaping is safer than cigarettes then we want smokers to vape, and if vaping can be made absolutely safe by changing how it's made and inspecting what is sold, then we should do that and as a society stop telling people not to vape. NPR is simply pushing the agenda of whoever is willing to give it money and send it press releases, and that's probably a lot of law firms looking for a new tobacco-style feeding frenzy and a bunch of government regulators and counterpart lobbyists considering collaborating on that. I would guess that there may have been internal lobbying at some point that would keep NPR from accepting money from tobacco companies anyway, and Altria isn't part of Kraft any more, so there's really no avenue for them to have a say in NPR content.