4 ms·
But by your same logic, while we might not have a 100% guaranteed idea that vaping is safe (I disagree we have "no idea", especially compared to other forms of
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
But by your same logic, while we might not have a 100% guaranteed idea that vaping is safe (I disagree we have "no idea", especially compared to other forms of tobacco use), but we do have a 100% guaranteed idea that smoking cigarettes is unsafe.
I certainly get all the hate against Juul - it is definitely well-deserved. But I still think vaping has an actual use case for people who are addicted to cigarettes who want another way to satisfy their nicotine cravings, especially in social situations.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAgreed it has a use case - but if it was truly just a harm reduction device then it could be prescribed by a doctor alongside other options like Chantix rather than being made widely available
- JamesBarney 7y agoNicorette is over the counter. And I don't understand the logic that harm reduction devices/drugs should be less available than the more dangerous drugs...
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAnd Chantix which was the example I used is prescription only But my broader point was that if your argument is that vaping is a method to quit smoking, then it should be regulated or proved as such and not sold like other tobacco products or with misleading messaging. Currently IQOS (Philip Morris International via Altria in the US market) is trying to get this signoff from the FDA I think, but just for marketing purposes (and yes, this is a different product category than vaping but still in the 'novel' tobacco replacement category) Edit Addition: I should just mention I'm more playing devils advocate on both sides of this as frankly I'm still trying to decide on my belief in this argument. I've been researching tobacco control for the last few months as part of a project and there are lots of valid arguments that many of the major vape companies and products are now owned by tobacco companies which have a history of being disingenuous at best and actively harmful/criminal at worst and so novel products like vapes should just be not trusted or even outlawed until the effects are known. But on the other side, available data so far does show that vapes generally are less harmful than cigarettes, so if someone is using it as a device to switch and that's the only thing that's an option for them (rather than quitting cold turkey) then it's not good to limit that option. But the math starts getting really fuzzy if you think about the number of new 'users' vaping and novel products could theoretically attract to a product that while probably not as harmful as cigarettes, isn't as good as not using anything at all https://www.chantix.com/faqs#how-do-i-get-chantix https://www.chantix.com/faqs#how-do-i-get-chantix
- executive 7y agoChantix sounds terrifying: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hp_y0wDFz0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hp_y0wDFz0
- CydeWeys 7y agoIt's a great example of a drug that absolutely should be prescription. But I'd you don't get the terrible side effects, and it helps you to quit, it's definitely worth taking it health-wise.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAh sorry for not being clearer, I just was talking about Chantix in particular being something that required a prescription But I'm actually not positive that it's proven it helps you quit. Here's an excerpt from a paper I was reading the other day "The study [21] of the effect of "real world" ENDS use on the population quit rates among 1284 U.S. adult smokers showed that the adjusted odds of quitting smoking were lower for those that used ENDS at baseline (9.4%) compared to smokers who did not use ENDS (18.9%). Smokers who used ENDS daily at some point during the study period were also less likely to quit smoking than nonusers (AOR = 0.17)." My notes are kind of messy but I think it's from this meta analysis http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/356561555100066200/pdf/E-Cigarettes-Use-and-Taxation.pdf http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/356561555100066200... I actually am a bit confused on the NHS' stance actually - they came out strong on this but many other agencies like the WHO seem to be taking much more of a wait and see approach
- JamesBarney 7y agoSorry I wasn't arguing chantix didn't require a prescription, only the rule "all quitting aids are prescribed" wasn't true. I also don't understand why if something helps you quit smoking we should make it less available? If it help people quit smoking we should make it more available, and if it doesn't then make it less. The UK royal academy of physicians and equivalent of nih think vaping probably has 5% of the risks of smoking. That means to break even we would need ~20 new vapers for every smoker who switches to vaping. And I don't think there is any way to look at the data and conclude there are 20 times as many new vapers as smokers who switched.
- drawkbox 7y agoPeople totally overlook the fact that cigarette butts are also one of the biggest problems in environmental pollution [1]. The market has come up with a solution, vaping and e-cigarettes that are safer already and do not damage the environment as much. I am strongly anti-prohibition and anti-banning as that leads to more problems in the black market and provides regulatory capture for big fish, cigarettes are fine as people choose to do with their body what they choose as it is their Right to Body. But if there is a better solution with vaping, and people are going to do it no matter what, banning and prohibitions will only lead to more involvement of mafias/cartels on the black market and give markets to big fish. This is a blue ocean market and about to open up massively when prohibition on marijuana ends, lots of big fish and mafias/cartels fighting to win it. Prohibitionists/authoritarians with agendas are just their pawns in this effort. The President looks to be doing an Executive Order soon to limit vaping, just like all the Republican governors that did it. [2][3] Same play different day, big fish win, "think of the children" authoritarianism and big fish disaster capitalist raiding of the blue ocean that will be immense when marijuana is fully legalized and vaping is suddenly "safe" when the bigs run the show. This is America. People not thinking it is about market power and money are naive as hell. You think this is for health reasons? laughable. Same with all bans and prohibitions, makes it more unsafe and more lucrative for mafias/cartels because there is decreased supply and increased demand, price goes up, in comes the underground and more danger. [1] https://www.sciencealert.com/cigarette-butts-are-our-most-common-trash-and-they-re-harming-plant-growth https://www.sciencealert.com/cigarette-butts-are-our-most-co... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/11/health/trump-vaping.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/11/health/trump-vaping.html [3] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-11-08/senior-white-house-official-says-fda-shouldn-t-regulate-tobacco https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-11-08/senior-wh...
- yumraj 7y ago> we do have a 100% guaranteed idea that smoking cigarettes is unsafe. Not trying to be pedantic, but I don't think we have data yet to compare % of smokers who get cancer and die, vs % of vapers who get the above lung problem and die, and other such metrics. In other words both are bad, saying vaping is ok because smoking is bad is doing everyone a disservice.
- theincredulousk 7y agoAgree with you, except the qualifier that “I certainly get all the hate against Juul”. I certainly don’t get it. Saw the news on a TV in a bar last night, talking about the Vitamin E oil. The video clip to go along was someone using a Juul! Juul is getting conflated to be synonymous with vaping, and that is patently wrong. I guess they should be sorry for creating the best product, that so happens to be discreet enough for teenagers to hide.
- ses1984 7y agoJuul knowingly sold tainted pods.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoJuul's marketing and advertising in the early days was pretty much designed to get teenagers hooked.