6 ms·
> Some patients say they vaped only nicotine, and state health officials consider some of those reports reliable, Dr. Schuchat said. A good warning to ignore a
by gpm 7y ago
> Some patients say they vaped only nicotine, and state health officials consider some of those reports reliable, Dr. Schuchat said.
A good warning to ignore all the people on HN who keep trying to insist that "oh, vaping is safe as long as you aren't doing X".
We have no idea if vaping is safe. We still have no idea if vaping is safe, except we explicitly know it is unsafe (to the point of acutely poisoning you) if it involves this chemical.
- e40 7y agoYeah, it's still early days in this: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/30/health/juul-pods-contaminated.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/30/health/juul-pods-contamin...
- sneak 7y agoVaping is orders of magnitude safer than smoking cigarettes. 9 total have died from vaping. 22,000 die every day from cigarette smoking.
- gpm 7y ago9 have died from acute poisoning from vaping. No one dies from that from cigarettes. Vaping hasn't been around long enough for us to see any long term effects similar to the ones caused by cigarettes.
- sneak 7y agoThat’s a false statement. Vaping has been around for fifteen years or more, and common for at least ten.
- gpm 7y agoSmoking has been around since at least the 1700s, it wasn't until something like 1950 that we managed to link it to lung cancer. 15 years is nothing... I'm not sure where to find numbers about the increase in lung cancer after smoking for only 15 years, but I know most studies look at people who have been smoking for more like 30 or 50 years...
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoYes, generally the health community has been talking about a minimum of 20 years to get 'long term' data on the effects of vaping Another problem they're dealing with is that we talk about vaping being one thing - in reality there are hundreds of companies with their own solutions. Of course there are some similarities in products and in the last few years Juul has come to dominate the US market, but other products (both the devices and the liquids) are of murky origin and quality. I was recently reading a study of a scientist looking into some devices and they found some contaminants that they didn't expect to be present at all that had no reason being there other than a use of cheap/incorrect/mistaken materials Source: various, I've been researching tobacco control broadly for the last ~5 months as part of a project, if anyone is interested I can pull together some of the more interesting reports I've read
- zeroonetwothree 7y agoThat’s not really long term in the same sense as cigarette effects on health.
- jeffdavis 7y agoMost people who die of cigarettes do so after quite a long time of using them. I'm not sure that the data are comparable yet.
- dmix 7y agoIndeed, we're far from knowing how safe ecigs probably about 5 more yrs until we know for sure, there's always a risk, but we're not anywhere close to knowing with certainty it's dangerous like cigarettes. All early evidence is showing vaping is far safer... even 2nd-hand smoke with vaping is way safer (no evidence of transfer via 2nd-hand smoke during vaping tests meanwhile cigarette smoke lingers around and hurts people). There was a reason this was a big deal because it was the first time showing a direct connection to being dangerous and now its again pointing back to a small subset of THC pens and those in the business of hysteria are trying to cover their bases.
- cma 7y ago>No one dies from that from cigarettes. Nicotine poisoning from cigarettes is a thing, toddlers that eat them can be affected.
- gpm 7y agoOk... but to be fair I'm pretty sure if the toddler ate the vape pen it would be even worse... And at least the webmd article on nicotine poisoning identifiers vaping as riskier (with respect to it) than smoking: https://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/nicotine-poisoning-can-you-overdose# https://www.webmd.com/smoking-cessation/nicotine-poisoning-c...
- cma 7y agoYes, I'd agree it is worse, more concentrated and I would think the candy-like flavors in use would probably make the liquid much more desirable to kids to drink.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoThe concept of carcinogens is that certain chemicals are known to cause cancer. We can reasonably believe that products that don't have carcinogens won't cause cancer.
- Tagbert 7y agoAre you assuming that vaping does not contain other carcinogens or that it does not cause other, possibly deadly, health issue? The issue is that we don’t know.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoWe also don't know a lot of things. Vaping could also be neuroprotective for Alzheimer's patients. 5G could cause heart disease.
- tinus_hn 7y agoSome chemicals are known carcinogens. Many others are unknown carcinogens. It isn’t even known what chemicals are in e-cigarettes. To believe smoking e-cigarettes or vaping can not cause cancer is just dumb. Inhaling just about anything can cause cancer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- drawkbox 7y agoVaping oil is much different than vaping flower or dry though. Vaping simply means non combusted smoke which since it is under 450 degrees it reduces and removes 20+ carcinogens. Noone thinks smoking is purely healthy, but comparing vaping to cigarettes it is a no brainer safer. Oils probably a little less safe than dry. Also, cigarette butts are next to plastics as the most environmental damage. e-cigs and vaping is mostly re-usable and there are no butts about it. 10 years and there was no issues, suddenly a bunch of them. If you ask me that is blue ocean market sabotage. The big fish are moving in. Altria bought Juul in December 2018, suddenly in 2019 all these issues and a big "think of the children" offensive that is typical in authoritarian and big fish take overs of markets or to keep something at the underground black market mafia level like drugs. Prohibition doesn't work, banning and outrage create danger, it only makes it more unsafe in production when people go to the black market when a legal market was progressing and becoming more and more safe. Dispensaries had they own safety state/independent organizations. If they truly want to make it more safe, they will decriminalize and legalize marijuana, end prohibition and make the production safer while taking out the black market competitors that caused this issue. This is America. People not thinking it is about market power and money are naive as hell. You think this is for health reasons? laughable. Same with all bans and prohibitions, makes it more unsafe and more lucrative for mafias/cartels because there is decreased supply and increased demand, price goes up, in comes the underground and more danger.
- MereInterest 7y ago> Noone thinks smoking is purely healthy, but comparing vaping to cigarettes it is a no brainer safer. And if vaping were only done as a way to quit smoking cigarettes, that would be a relevant fact. When more teenagers have vaped than have smoked[1], this is clearly not the case. It is being treated as something entirely new and distinct from cigarettes, and should therefore be compared against not vaping. Yes, regulate it and make sure that it is safe. That includes taking products off the market while investigating unknown health issues. Regulate it and control the allowed marketing for it. That includes not allowing the advertising of addictive substances to minors. [1] https://www.drugabuse.gov/related-topics/trends-statistics/infographics/teens-e-cigarettes https://www.drugabuse.gov/related-topics/trends-statistics/i...
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoBut by your same logic, while we might not have a 100% guaranteed idea that vaping is safe (I disagree we have "no idea", especially compared to other forms of tobacco use), but we do have a 100% guaranteed idea that smoking cigarettes is unsafe. I certainly get all the hate against Juul - it is definitely well-deserved. But I still think vaping has an actual use case for people who are addicted to cigarettes who want another way to satisfy their nicotine cravings, especially in social situations.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAgreed it has a use case - but if it was truly just a harm reduction device then it could be prescribed by a doctor alongside other options like Chantix rather than being made widely available
- JamesBarney 7y agoNicorette is over the counter. And I don't understand the logic that harm reduction devices/drugs should be less available than the more dangerous drugs...
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAnd Chantix which was the example I used is prescription only But my broader point was that if your argument is that vaping is a method to quit smoking, then it should be regulated or proved as such and not sold like other tobacco products or with misleading messaging. Currently IQOS (Philip Morris International via Altria in the US market) is trying to get this signoff from the FDA I think, but just for marketing purposes (and yes, this is a different product category than vaping but still in the 'novel' tobacco replacement category) Edit Addition: I should just mention I'm more playing devils advocate on both sides of this as frankly I'm still trying to decide on my belief in this argument. I've been researching tobacco control for the last few months as part of a project and there are lots of valid arguments that many of the major vape companies and products are now owned by tobacco companies which have a history of being disingenuous at best and actively harmful/criminal at worst and so novel products like vapes should just be not trusted or even outlawed until the effects are known. But on the other side, available data so far does show that vapes generally are less harmful than cigarettes, so if someone is using it as a device to switch and that's the only thing that's an option for them (rather than quitting cold turkey) then it's not good to limit that option. But the math starts getting really fuzzy if you think about the number of new 'users' vaping and novel products could theoretically attract to a product that while probably not as harmful as cigarettes, isn't as good as not using anything at all https://www.chantix.com/faqs#how-do-i-get-chantix https://www.chantix.com/faqs#how-do-i-get-chantix
- dr_dshiv 7y ago"Safe" is a misleading goal. For instance, sunlight causes cancer. People should simply be aware of the risks and their probability.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoYeah, if federal government agents were interviewing me, as a minor, I might also deny consuming a schedule 1 drug. There is NO verifiable evidence that consumer nicotine ecigs have caused any deaths.
- belltaco 7y agoArticle states state health dept employees.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoStrongly second this - the data is just not out there yet on the long term effects of vaping (and keep in mind we use the term vaping broadly but there are hundreds of companies that produce devices of varied quality). Of course, the harm reduction qualities make it interesting, but I heard a tobacco control researcher explain it like this (not exact quote) - Imagine that smoking tobacco is like jumping out of a building on the 100th story, most likely vaping is not as bad, but there's no consensus on whether you're jumping out of the 99th story or the 2nd The best thing to do for your health (if that's what you're optimizing for) is to just quit and not replace with a new device. The CDC has a bunch of resources as do most Western Nations in the local languages. Below is a link to the tobacco cessation mobile app from the CDC https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/campaign/tips/quit-smoking/quitstart-app/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/campaign/tips/quit-smoking/quits...
- JamesBarney 7y agoSo we do have a lot of research on how bad just nicotine is for you. And it's close to 5% as harmful. We also know how bad polyethylene glycol is for you, and it's not that bad(it's used in medical devices). So most of the unknown risk is concentrated around device and flavorings.
- EpicEng 7y ago>We have no idea if vaping is safe. We still have no idea if vaping is safe, except we explicitly know it is unsafe (to the point of acutely poisoning you) if it involves this chemical. Sure. In other news: don't vape bleach. It's bad for you. I mean really. No nicotine vaping liquid has vitamin E in it as there's no reason to put it in there.
- ddingus 7y agoWe do know it is important in harm reduction. Whatever problems vape brings to the table will be much nicer problems to have when compared to cigarettes.