6 ms·
> At that point the ultrawealthy will seek to form an alliance with the growing popularity of the far right and seek to annihilate the left. That’s a weird cha
by rayiner 7y ago
> At that point the ultrawealthy will seek to form an alliance with the growing popularity of the far right and seek to annihilate the left.
That’s a weird characterization, given that the trend has been in the opposite direction: https://www.vox.com/polyarchy/2016/6/3/11843780/democrats-wealthy-party https://www.vox.com/polyarchy/2016/6/3/11843780/democrats-we...
Also, frankly, the attempt to make it seem like the “left” has a monopoly on “people of color” and “immigrants” is offensive. Trump got almost 30% of the Hispanic vote, and it’s not because of the lovely things he said about Hispanic people. Abbott got over 40% of the Hispanic vote in Texas.
The idea that billionaires are going to form a coalition with nazis to oppress “people of color” is a leftist fever dream.
- claudeganon 7y agoI would say the ultrawealthy’s cooption of the Democratic Party, moving it away from anything like a class-based politics, has actually been one of the more effective forms of undermining and destroying the left.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mark_l_watson 7y ago+1 I almost totally agree with you. We may differ in opinion somewhat because I think that both the DNC and RNC cater to the ultra wealthy, and the democrat and republican machines compete to get votes and more support from the ultra wealthy by both doing anything the ultra wealthy want them to. For the Democrats, I am not talking about AOC and Bernie Sanders (who will always be demonized in the media) but referring to most democratic politicians (and Republicans, of course) who bend over backwards to protect corporate interests.
- Amygaz 7y agoAOC isn't anti-wealth, she is anti-greed, and with good reason, because greedy people are psychopaths. If you align your MO with hers, you'll be just fine, even as an ultra wealthy. Currently, the billionaires in this country are split pretty much equally between the two sides, the same way the country is split pretty much equally. They are a good representation of the society we created here. While many on HN know that model is flawed, unsustainable, and that we need to try something new, we also know that dinosaurs have a hard them to let go. The movie, music, and video game industries are example of groups led by greedy dinosaurs who resisted changes brought by the internet. With AOC, we should be promoting and rewarding community success, as opposed to that of an individual like we do with the current pseudo-merit travesty system that we have. I do not see how this conflict with being highly profitable. I actually think that more people would be more motivated and more profitable with a more inclusive system.
- yourbandsucks 7y agoThis development is actually terrifying. If socialism has no home on the left, we'll see it rise on the right, with nationalist tones.
- acollins1331 7y agoYou saw it take hold in 2016. Obama got the populist votes, and then Trump did. People wonder how the same people could vote for both, the common thread is populism.
- bobthepanda 7y agoWhat would you describe about Obama as “populist”?
- acollins1331 7y agoHis rhetoric and promises during campaigns
- claudiawerner 7y agoThe US Democritic Party is a very far cry from "the left"; you only have to look at the policies of the biggest candidates (perhaps with the exception of Sanders) to see that. The theory of the Overton Window captures this quite well, as do the history of the social democratic parties in Europe and later the US. GP's point is primarily historical, and as such in Nazi Germany "the left" would absolutely refer to the Marxist parties, the parties in support of the German Revolution, etc. This has actually been noticed as early as the 60s, and perhaps even earlier. From Marcuse's One-Dimensional Man: >The British Labor Party, whose leaders compete with their Con-servative counterparts in advancing national interests, is hard put to save even a modest program of partial nationalization. In West Germany, which has outlawed the Communist Party, the Social Democratic Party, having officially rejected its Marxist programs, is convincingly proving its respectability. This is the situation in the leading industrial countries of the West. In the East, the gradual reduction of direct political controls testifies to increas-ing reliance on the effectiveness of technological controls as instruments of domination. As for the strong Communist parties in France and Italy, they bear witness to the general trend of circumstances by adhering to a minimum program which shelves the revolutionary seizure of power and complies with the rules of the parliamentary game.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoFrom a UK perspective the USA has two parties of the right, varying only in degree. :) The UK Labour Party didn't really cease being of the left and away from nationalisation until 1983, which started the march to being "Tory Lite" of Blair's New Labour. [1] Around 1980 the centrist people split away from the party to form the SDP (they would much later merge with the liberals to become the LibDems). What killed the left was "the longest suicide note in history" - Michael Foot's 1983 Election Manifesto. 1983 was the early election that Thatcher used to cash in the Falklands dividend. The Tories were on course for a major loss, or at best scrape a hung parliament prior to the Falklands, after they got a doubled majority and the pattern of the rest of the decade was set. No Labour manifesto policies could have answered that. Yet between that and the SDP it started the journey to Blairism, and almost destruction of the party. Brexit may end up doing similar to the Tory party - they've kicked many of their moderates. Depending what the December election brings, it could get ugly... Bring popcorn. [1] OK, if you want to be pedantic, the IMF loan Healey got in 1974, and subsequent IMF supervision kicked them toward the centre -- temporarily. Everyone remembers it was Healey -- no one remembers the negotiations started the moment they got elected because the Tories left no public finances, and of course there was that minor oil crisis. :)
- richmarr 7y ago> That’s a weird characterization, given that the trend has been in the opposite direction:... I don't think you've adequately supported that criticism. The article you're citing discusses the "top 4%" of income earners. That's a very different thing to "billionaires" of which there are 607 [Edit: in the USA].
- yabadabadoes 7y agoThe photo of a Clinton is also a prime example of left party gone center-right based on support from the billionaires and the (rest of the 4%). Since the US has a FPTP system, the first layer of fighting is for both party nominations and is poor majority against (centrist) rich minority, which would have a clearer outcome if money in politics had clearer rules. Edit- clarity
- claudeganon 7y ago> Also, frankly, the attempt to make it seem like the “left” has a monopoly on “people of color” and “immigrants” is offensive. Trump got almost 30% of the Hispanic vote, and it’s not because of the lovely things he said about Hispanic people. Abbott got over 40% of the Hispanic vote in Texas. The idea that billionaires are going to form a coalition with nazis to oppress “people of color” is a leftist fever dream. That’s not what the parent said, they said that the right scapegoats various minority groups as a way of dividing the lower classes and bringing segments of them into alliance with itself. It’s true that fascistic scapegoating doesn’t operate along standard US racial frames, but not that the right won’t resort to them. The other thing you’re eliding is the incoherent tribalism inherent to fascist ideologies. Since they have no real commitment to meaning or truth, all it takes is identification with their precepts and a particular authoritarian manifestation to adhere to them.
- spamizbad 7y agoThe OP is talking about the future, your political demographic numbers are the present. For example, the Republican Party used to enjoy the majority of the black vote, but this shifted towards the Democrats during the latter half of the 20th century. Likewise, prior to 9/11, the Republican Party enjoyed the majority of Muslim voters, who shifted their support leftward in the following decade. As for the Democrats, they used to have much stronger support from the white working class, but this once reliable voting bloc started eroding away from them since the 1970s. The sustained economic prosperity of the post war years in the US mainstreamed market liberalism for Baby Boomers and Gen-Xers, giving birth to “neoliberalism”, rejecting their parent’s depression-era “new deal Democrats” skepticism of unfettered market capitalism. Political demographics aren’t set in stone. They will change with events of the nation.
- RickJWagner 7y agoYou're right about shifting demographics. I'm particularly interested in watching African-American voting sentiments in the age of Trump. He seems to be bringing change.
- pytester 7y agoPrecisely. The democratic party would be weimaresque almost to a fault under Clinton or Biden, just as it was under Obama. If AOC, Sanders and Warren took the reins of the party, they'd not only lose all support from billionaires, they'd go into vicious attack mode, funding whomever they thought could defeat them - both inside and outside the party. I also wouldn't want to presuppose who the "other" might end up being. The far right might very well embrace Jews, Hispanics and Blacks while they turn on immigrants and muslims. But, there will be an "other" and their "otherness" will become a bigger and bigger deal over time.
- claudeganon 7y agoGiven that Warren has spent much of her recent campaign hedging away from Medicare for All, defending the existence of billionaires, and coordinating with the Clintons, I think actually the billionaires would be just fine with her.
- rriepe 7y agoFever dreams is how they operate. They portray their outgroup as Saturday morning cartoon villains and then they start digging mass graves. Pytester: If you're in the Bay Area, please get lunch with me. You are insanely bigoted and hateful against conservatives. Have you talked to a real conservative in the last five years? I have never seen such hate-filled tripe on HN.
- thebooktocome 7y agoHow condescending.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jcims 7y agoJust saw this yesterday. John Cleese on Extremism - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLNhPMQnWu4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLNhPMQnWu4
- ghemsley 7y agoI do believe Pytester said "far-right". Most people understand them as being different from your typical conservative.
- WalterGR 7y agoFever dreams is how they operate. They portray their outgroup as Saturday morning cartoon villains and then they start digging mass graves. Then You are insanely bigoted and hateful against conservatives. Have you talked to a real conservative in the last five years? You do see the irony here, yes?
- selimthegrim 7y agoIf you think that say Ted Cruz has any respect for his Hispanic voters (just see the game he plays with Beto's nickname) you're only kidding yourself
- vuln 7y agoIs Robert Francis O'Rourke Hispanic?
- selimthegrim 7y agoDoes Rafael Cruz think they need to be told that in such a way that it’s an electoral issue?
- umanwizard 7y agoExactly one of Beto and Ted Cruz are Hispanic, and it isn’t Beto...
- rayiner 7y agoTed Cruz took pot shots at Beto’s nickname because it won points with his bloc of Hispanic voters: https://www.thedailybeast.com/meet-the-hispanic-voters-who-may-save-ted-cruz-from-beto-orourke https://www.thedailybeast.com/meet-the-hispanic-voters-who-m... It’s a way for Cruz to signal membership as part of the large minority of Hispanic Americans who are religious, anti-socialist, and have conservative views on abortion, crime, drugs, etc. It’s a shrewd way to stake out and define a distinct identity for minorities who lean conservative. Look at Sajid Javid in the U.K. (where the Tories are in the verge of pulling in the majority of the Indian vote): https://www.politico.eu/article/conservatives-lure-south-asian-brits/ https://www.politico.eu/article/conservatives-lure-south-asi... > “Most ethnic minorities believe in the Conservative values of family, self-reliance and aspiration.”
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoWhy did Trump get 30% of the Hispanic vote? In South Florida, Hispanics love him (yet he can famously be heard talking about building a wall, which would have kept them and their family out)
- lr4444lr 7y agoPerhaps because news media, created by people no less fallible than you and I, are intent on casting him and his supporters in a certain light. Many directing this will claim fears, some real, some imagined. Personally, I'm more disturbed by the implication behind the congratulatory applause they gave at his predecessor's send off from the final Whitehouse correspondents dinner.
- JeffL 7y agoI'm sure there are as many reasons as people, but I would guess one common thread might be that the ones who came here legally resent the ones that broke the law to come here.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoIf somebody's family came from Cuba on a tire raft, does that most likely mean they did not come over legally?
- umanwizard 7y agoNo, it doesn't. If they came before 2017, they were legal the instant their tire raft touched US soil. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_feet,_dry_feet_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_feet,_dry_feet_policy
- umanwizard 7y agoHispanics in South Florida (or their ancestors) came by sea, not land. A wall wouldn’t have kept them out. Despite US culture’s obsession with slotting people into racial categories like “Hispanic”, Cubans in Florida actually have very little in common with Mexicans and Mexican-Americans in California, Texas and the Southwest.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>The idea that billionaires are going to form a coalition with nazis to oppress “people of color” is a leftist fever dream. This is a fairly apt description of the Southern Strategy that Nixon rode to power.
- bilbo0s 7y agoUnfortunate reality is that inciting hatred towards, let's call them "The Other", is just good political business in a representative democracy. You have to get elected in a representative democracy. Which means people need to vote for you. Tribalism, for all it's faults, can accomplish one task exceedingly well, and that's getting people to vote for you. Doesn't make you racist or a bad person to concede, in a debate, that which really is just millennia on millennia of human evolutionary biology at work. Does it make politicians irresponsible when they employ tribalism? Absolutely. No question. But it's abundantly clear the left and the right employ that strategy all the time.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoThis sounds nice, until you look at what Nixon did as president and what he said behind closed doors. He was both a racist and a bad person.
- bilbo0s 7y agoWhich is why I said the politicians are irresponsible. When I said you're not a bad person if you concede that politicians employ tribalist strategies, I was talking about the commenters on this forum not the politicians themselves. Many commenters here appear to be testing the extents of mental flexibility in order to render their side of the political divide innocent of tribalism. I assume they are doing so because they believe conceding that fact is tantamount to being a racist. My assertion is that conceding this fact is not racist, it's just laying out contemporary political realities. It's just laying out behavioral evolution. We, as in "our society", put the screws to certain groups, because in our society doing so delivers votes. When it no longer delivers votes, maybe we won't do it? But for now, it's just how the game is played. And all political sides play this game. It's just that different political sides put the screws to different "tribal" groups. And some tribes have the rare misfortune of coming under pressure by all political sides. Nixon is obviously a good example of a politician who used tribalism to his benefit. I don't argue that at all. Because, again, conceding that doesn't make me a bad person or a racist. Just makes me a guy stating a fact.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- opnitro 7y agoYour link conflates "the democrats" with "the left"