3 ms·
> My mileage did vary. Nobody in modern academic philosophy is a dualist. That may not be as true as you think. Notice the high percentages of internalism, lib
by gwern 16y ago
> My mileage did vary. Nobody in modern academic philosophy is a dualist.
That may not be as true as you think. Notice the high percentages of internalism, libertarianism, and other positions associated with dualism. (Unfortunately, the survey didn't ask flat out about dualism):
http://philpapers.org/surveys/results.pl http://philpapers.org/surveys/results.pl
- randallsquared 16y agoNote that "libertarianism" here refers to an argument about free will, not political libertarianism.
- gwern 16y ago? I know perfectly well what libertarianism refers to here, that's why I mentioned it in the context of a philosophy of mind discussion.
- randallsquared 16y agoSince you're the one who used it, I assumed you knew what it means. :) I was confused, because (not having taken any philosophy classes since 1990) I didn't recognize the term as anything but political. I thought other people might similarly be confused if they weren't familiar with the philosophical use of "libertarian".
- mbateman 16y agoMind: physicalism or non-physicalism? Accept or lean toward: physicalism 526 / 931 (56.4%) Accept or lean toward: non-physicalism 252 / 931 (27%) Other 153 / 931 (16.4%) Not sure how you can pick "other" from those options, but there you have it. (Physicalism implies non-dualism. Non-physicalism does not imply dualism.)
- gwern 16y ago> Physicalism implies non-dualism. Non-physicalism does not imply dualism. Since they didn't ask about dualism directly, nor, as far as I can tell, any position that logically entails dualism, obviously there is no deductive implication here. I'm making a probabilistic point - non-physicalism is heavily represented (more than a quarter) among the group Samd specified, and thus there are pretty good odds that at least one academic philosopher espouses the specific non-physicalist theory of dualism.
- mbateman 16y agoYes lots of them do (e.g. Chalmers), but most of them don't by a fair margin.
- samd 16y agoLet's go with: nobody's a Cartesian dualist.