3 ms·
This article is kind of pop science history. Here is the Wright Patent: https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/1c/17/b5/e1f4968143a568/US821393.pdf https:/
by rayiner 7y ago
This article is kind of pop science history. Here is the Wright Patent: https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/1c/17/b5/e1f4968143a568/US821393.pdf https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/1c/17/b5/e1f4968...
The patent disclosed the theory of using ailerons for control. Claim 1 refers to “lateral marginal portions” of the wing “capable of movement to different positions above and below the normal plane of the airplane.” That’s an aileron.
The embodiment in the patent happened to use a warping wing, but as a matter of physics and the patent drafting, the invention was using such lateral movable surfaces for control, not a particular way of building such a surface.
Additionally, the article fails to note the importance of patents to the other side. The Arial Experimental Association was bankrolled by Alexander Graham Bell. Bell had relied heavily on patents to secure investor capital that he used to build his business and eventually his research lab. See: http://digitalcommons.law.utulsa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2980&context=tlr http://digitalcommons.law.utulsa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art.... (The same is true, incidentally, for Edison.)
One of the fictions we indulge is that invention is all about inventors. In fact, it’s at least as much about investors. The aviation patent wars is much easier to understand if you look at the business and investment structures that created American airplane companies in the first place: https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=421000089122085071066090119088101031057007068045058024089023089126083022086084026010033060122005052003049115064016001092111080112008078077085086091028096070076110124000078053121076086112119117005002090122065071065068100100014015089109123090103092116114&EXT=pdf https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=4210000891220850...
- dboreham 7y agoI had that penny dropping epiphany years ago, and it's great to see it repeated here: patents are for the investor class who are accustomed to dealing with pieces of paper that represent value: stocks, bonds, mortgages, warrants, copyright, trademarks. Patents are really an attempt to fit what we do into their world of value-paper. The fact that there's a significant impedance mismatch underlies all the problems with patents.
- vanderZwan 7y agoThat sounds interesting. Could you elaborate on that for those of us who might get lost in the terse jargon there?
- dboreham 7y agoHmm...not sure how to expand on what I said. Perhaps an example will help: If you go to a bank asking to borrow money they might ask "what collateral do you have to secure a loan?". If you own a house, they would ask you to bring in the property title document to prove to them that you own it (or some title company would do that work for them). Patents can serve a similar purpose: you want to borrow money from an investor to develop a product idea into a commercial product: they might say "what patents do you have?". To them, the patent document serves a similar purpose to the property title in the bank loan case: a piece of paper that makes them think there's something of value that they can ultimately take from you or sell if the company doesn't succeed, or at least something that gives them a warmer and fuzzier feeling that if you were just saying "Trust me I know what I'm doing".
- beerandt 7y ago>That’s an aileron. I'd argue it's not. (But I still believe the patents other claims, and as a whole was obviously violated.) You can't go of of the language of today to judge the claim. After all, the Wright brothers use "flying machine" to describe what we call an "airplane", and the term "aeroplane" to describe what we call a "wing". Remember, the method and implementation is what's patentable, not the concept. It doesn't really matter if we'd call a warped wing an aileron or not, or that it accomplishes the same objective. It only matters how the implementation of the invention is described, and what elements are claimed (and in what combinations).
- Merrill 7y agoEdison was later backed by the big venture capitalists of his day -- JP Morgan, Vanderbilts, etc.