4 ms·
My objection to this is that terrorist attacks are extremely rare events and there is not that much data about them so trading on this market would be very bori
by guelo 16y ago
My objection to this is that terrorist attacks are extremely rare events and there is not that much data about them so trading on this market would be very boring and you would almost always lose the boom bet. Anyway, anti-terrorism efforts seem like misplaced priorities, if you really want to save the lives of American you're better off working on ways to reduce car crashes or ways to stop people from eating cheeseburgers.
- gwern 16y agoThe markets were going to be about more long-term trends and political events - the sort of things analysts usually grapple with. This too is one of the common under-informed criticisms.
- guelo 16y agoTFA: "Under the plan, traders would buy and sell futures contracts on specific events such as terrorist attacks, based on whether they believed they would happen. " How do you make a bet on a long-term trend? What kind of long-term trends? Political events?
- gwern 16y ago> "In fact, however, PAM was not intended to forecast the details of terrorist attacks. It was instead intended to forecast aggregate measures of geopolitical stability in the Middle East. PAM would have used speculative markets to estimate economic growth, political stability, and military activity four times a year in each of eight nations, and how those measures would depend on each other and on various U.S. policy choices. PAMs designers thought their plan ambitious enough without also tackling the added complexities of predicting terrorism." -- http://hanson.gmu.edu/realterf.pdf http://hanson.gmu.edu/realterf.pdf (Hm, how would one estimate things like economic growth? That sounds really hard and my imagination just fails to think of any way to measure a long-term trend like that!)
- gwern 16y agoAnother relevant quote: > "Our focused later narrowed to a smaller region, the Mideast, because the Economist Intelligence Unit charged a high price to judge after the fact what instability had actually occurred in each nation. The final plan was to cover eight nations. For each nation in each quarter of a year (over the two year final phase), traders would estimate five parameters: its military activity, political instability, economic growth, US military activity, and US financial involvement. In addition traders would predict US GDP, world trade, US military casualties, and western terrorist casualties, and a few miscellaneous items, to be determined by traders and the EIU. This would require (8 × 8 × 5 =) a hundred or so base markets. > > In addition, we planned to let traders predict combinations of these events, such has how moving US troops out of Saudi Arabia would effect political stability there, how that would effect stability in neighboring nations, and how all that might change oil prices. Similar trades could have predicted the local and global consequences of invading Iraq, had such markets been ready then. (More on this in the later section on combinatorics section.)"